I’m not a multiplayer-gamer (yet, other than Borderlands 2), so the choice would have to be based on the single player mode.
Haven’t tried any JRPG’s yet, but I’ve heard a lot of good things about Persona 5, so I’ve been curious.
Sniper Elite interests me since being a sniper is my favourite part of all shooters.
Other than that, the kinds of games I love are The Witcher, Mass Effect, Uncharted, Dragon Age, Diablo III, Assassins Creed and I’ve enjoyed a lot of the other COD campaigns.
So yeah, the story is probably the most important part =)