2020 Match 1 of The Resistance: Avalon

All joking aside that’s my actual haircut, except I added a layer of skin.

I might have worded this all sorts of wrong

Whose skin?

Where is Tricia Helfer these days??

We’re waiting for the team vote results, right?

Actually she does a BSG podcast, episode by episode, it’s pretty frakkin’ good.

Proposed Team 2A:
rowe33 <- leader
snebmi
jorn
rho21

Team 2A Vote Results:
@caseyrobinson - No
@rho21 - No
@rowe33 - Yes
@knightsaber - Yes
@cuthbert - No
@soondifferent - Yes
@scottagibson - No
@craigm - No
@jorn_weines - Yes
@snebmi - Yes

The mission does not go forward. @Knightsaber please propose 2B.

I still think Rowe, me, Jorn and someone else with the spotlight on that person is our best bet.

Hokay, I’ll go with myself, @rowe33, @Snebmi and @Jorn_Weines then.

@Lantz

Proposed Team 2b:
@knightsaber <- leader
@rowe33
@snebmi
@jorn_weines

All Players Please Vote (If you haven’t already):
@caseyrobinson
@rho21
@rowe33 Strong Leader
@knightsaber
@cuthbert
@soondifferent
@scottagibson
@craigm
@jorn_weines In the Spotlight
@snebmi Chicago Proxy

Team 2B Vote Results:
@caseyrobinson - No
@rho21 - No
@rowe33 - Yes
@knightsaber - Yes
@cuthbert - Yes
@soondifferent - No
@scottagibson - No
@craigm - No
@jorn_weines - Yes
@snebmi - Yes

The vote is 5-5 the team is a no go.

@Cuthbert please propose 2C

So, it appears the attempt to reverse-engineer the trust train is not working, I’ll go in a different direction.

Myself
@Knightsaber
@soondifferent
@scottagibson

Proposed Team 2C:
@cuthbert <- leader
@knightsaber
@soondifferent
@scottagibson

All Players Please Vote (If you haven’t already):
@caseyrobinson
@rho21
@rowe33 Strong Leader
@knightsaber
@cuthbert
@soondifferent
@scottagibson
@craigm
@jorn_weines In the Spotlight
@snebmi Chicago Proxy

There are four people in the chain - me, Casey, Rowe, Jorn - and this mission takes four out of the remainder. If there are 4 Evils in the chain, this mission has a 100% (6/6 to the fourth power) chance of being clean. If there are three, there is a 48% (5/6 to the fourth power) chance of this mission being clean. If there are two, there is a 20% (4/6 to the fourth power) chance of this mission being clean. If there is one, there is a 6% (3/6 to the fourth power) chance of this mission being clean.

Plus, what does this mission tell us? I’m not exactly sure why the spotlight-and-either-Rowe-is-confirmed-Evil-or-we’re-2-0 plan keeps getting rejected, but what will we know if this mission fails? We’ll have no clue who to blame and we’ll have lost our lead. In what way would this mission help at all?

In summary: the odds of a clean mission are low and we’ll learn nothing from a failure.

I could choose myself and three of you, but there’s no indication that will be accepted where the other ones weren’t

I tried, the people said no.

Its a team of 4 people, containing precisely zero of the people from an already successful mission.

Meaning that you would have to have an evil on mission one, given the votes a possibility with some weight towards rowe as evil so evil voted yes to give him cards, and get all four other good players correct.

Which the odds of picking 4 of 4 good players from a pool of 7 (assuming there was evil on 1) is very poor. And if 1 was clean and the votes were camouflage? Then we really are hosed with no members.

Also the way @Snebmi is trying to manipulate the Spotlight choice feels somewhat in search of motivated justification.

I know. I’m not sure why.