2020 Match 4 of The Resistance: Avalon

Yah I’m doing the 24 hours.

Yeah we totally hated that team.

I was on it so I liked that part.

This will be 1B right?

I wanted to hand out plot cards, plus I generally can’t decide whether I like voting yes or no on the first time. IRL I vote no and here I vote yes.

I forgot to reply in here so it would auto-track this thread. So here I am!

I kind of like maybe thought I was doing quest A, B, and C or something. So yeah 1B. Ugh.

No one told me there would be math!

I always switcheroo that accidentally at the beginning.

Any day now would be lovely.

I had a plan and then decided that everyone would think I was Evil if I did it. Then I forgot. One minute.

Snebmi, Lantz, Perky

@Knightsaber

Because if scott’s bad maybe he picked a good team other than him and if he’s good then his picks are as good as mine. Also everyone hated that team which is a potential indicator of goodness.

Accepting votes for Team 1B.

Team 1B - Snebmi, Lantz, Perky_Goth

@scottagibson
@Snebmi
@jostly
@soondifferent
@CaseyRobinson
@rowe33
@Lantz
@Perky_Goth

No Confidence - rowe33
In The Spotlight - CaseyRobinson

Well, it sounds reasonable…

Team 1B is pfffht.

Team 1B - Snebmi, Lantz, Perky_Goth

@scottagibson - No
@Snebmi - Yes
@jostly - No
@soondifferent - No
@CaseyRobinson - No
@rowe33 - Yes
@Lantz - Yes
@Perky_Goth - No

No Confidence - rowe33
In The Spotlight - CaseyRobinson

@jostly please name Team 1C

What do we know so far?

  1. There’s a No Confidence in play, so if we reject 1D we face the possibility of instant evil win
  2. 1A was approved by 2, 1B by 3, same as 1A + rowe

It seems unlikely to me that 3 evil approved 1B (because that would be double evil on the team), so I conclude it is likely at least 1 evil rejected the team. The question is whether that is because of early voting preference for rejection, or whether it has useful information about the team members.

It’s hard to draw any conclusions about team votes until we have a quest result or two for comparison.

Agreed, and since my workday is done now and I guess people in the weird timezones have woken up, I’m going to go ahead and post a team so we get on with it.

I’ll follow the same reasoning as Snebmi and suggest Team 1C to be:
jostly Lantz Perky_Goth

@Knightsaber

Accepting votes for Team 1C.

Team 1C - jostly, Lantz, Perky_Goth

@scottagibson
@Snebmi
@jostly
@soondifferent
@CaseyRobinson
@rowe33
@Lantz
@Perky_Goth

No Confidence - rowe33
In The Spotlight - CaseyRobinson