5 best video game series of all time


#166

While I actually love Planescape Torment, I’m not sure I would personally include it as part of this series. While it shares some basic mechanics from the engine, it really feels like something completely separate to me. One of my favorite gaming experiences of all time? Definitely, but not part of a series in my mind.


#167

Maybe we can include Planescape Torment as part of a series constituted by it and KOTOR2?


#168

Ah yeah, the “what can change the nature of a man, and what difference does that make” series!


#169

Just want to add that The Sims series is pretty much the only game series I consistently like over the years. Dolling up people is kind of fun (!). Building my dream home is kind of fun as well. Making social drama or play the traditional career progression “game”? Not so much.

In fact in most games nowadays there is option to doll up the avatar. I spent far too much time dolling up my dude/chick in perfect camo gear in Ghost Recon Wildlands, for one.

The Sims got kind of stale though. I played a crap ton of Sims 1 and 3, and in many respects they are the same game, one is just prettier than the other. Prettiness matters though.


#170

You’re probably right. Been a while since I’ve played those first three TR titles. Still, those games were nowhere as graphic…sure, part of it is because of the technological limits of the day, but it’s also the direction. Some of those death animations were totally unnecessary.


#171

That was a hard series to NOT have in my top 5. Super Metroid is my favorite game of all time. The GBA games and Metroid Prime were all great games. Just picked up the last 3DS one, looking forward to it.

Also could have put Castlevania on that list now that I think of it.


#172

Yes, Twilight 2000 is a good game for people who like making characters. However, I believe Darklands to be a better choice if character creation is what you’re after.


#173

You could say that, but I think you would quickly realize that you are most definitely wrong. That’s not me making that claim. That’s just the universe we live in. I don’t argue with the universe.


#174

Favorites in parentheses
1. Command and Conquer (Red Alert, but Generals comes in as a close 2nd)
2. Civilization (2)
3. Baldur’s Gate (2 of course, but I would like to include all the Infinity Engine games as part of the series)
4. GTA (5, but Vice City holds a special place in my heart)
5. The Elder Scrolls (Morrowind because it was my first)

Honorable mention: Need for Speed (haven’t played any in the series in awhile, but Most Wanted was my favorite)


#175

Ah. But do you yell at clouds?


#176

That’s different. That’s just nature. Not something important, like the Univere’s will and the ranking of early 90’s PC games.


#177

(LTTP but I had most of this reply in the cache so might as well post!)

Tough question. What makes a series best, as opposed to an individual game? A bunch of series are basically iterations on the same core, like Mario Kart. A great game, but you could probably make do with just your favorite iteration of it and let the rest of the games in the series go.

The same is true of many strategy series, Civ especially. So even though it’s the game series I’ve probably spent the most hours playing, I wouldn’t say Civ my favorite series as such; I’d just say Civ IV is one of my favorite games.

And how do you judge a series when not all parts of it are equally good? The game series I’m most looking forward to the next iteration of is The Witcher, but by the same token I’m not especially fond of Witcher 1 (it’s not bad, either, just there.) The Fallout games contain some of my favorite moments in all of gaming, but each individual game, including the first two, has substantial flaws in with the amazing stuff.

But let’s skip over this dithering about definitions. As an entire series I’d say my favorite is Ultima. Most of them, and especially 4-7, were excellent for their day (and created the open world genre.) Just as importantly each iteration tried to do something very different within the established framework. 5 isn’t just the same as 4 but with fancier graphics, but is actually a commentary on the design of 4.


#178

If I rank by playtime I’d go:

  1. Civilization
  2. Age of Empires
  3. Disgaea
  4. Sims
  5. Warcraft (If you can throw WOW in with Warcraft II).

#179

This is a tough poll for me. Some franchises change ownership and/or release some real stinkers. As far as consistency goes, most of the top series probably are (or were at some point) Nintendo exclusives IMO. Otherwise I would have to limit series to within a range of years as opposed to the whole series run.


#180

This list goes to 11:

1st place, with everything else following a long distance behind: The Thief games (1 - 3). Never before or since have I been so enthralled with games as much as these.

2nd place: The Stalker games.
3rd place: The Sniper: Elite games.
4th place: The early Tomb Raider games (1 - 3).
5th place: The Elite games.

Runners Up:
6th: The Call Of Juarez games.
7th: The Far Cry games.
8th: The Doom games.
9th: The short-lived Vietcong series.
10th: The Alone In The Dark games (1 - 3).
11th: The Carnivores games.

As you can probably tell, I play only on PC.


#181

Holy shit that’s an interesting list you got there @Giles_Habibula!


#182

Let’s see if I can come up with 5 franchises I love.

1. Monster Hunter Definitely my all time favorite franchise by a pretty large margin. Been playing these since the first game on PSP (later played the PS2 game as well).

2. Street Fighter I am never any good at these but I’ve been a fan since SF2 in arcades and on SNES. Just fun, even if I can’t seem to dedicate the time to learning it for real. SF5 is probably me best effor tto learn though.

3. Dark Souls I’d include Demon’s Souls and Bloodbourne in this as well. Terrific series and Demon’s Souls very much blew my hair back when I first played it. One of those games I thought about even when I wasn’t plaing it.

4. Gran Turismo Love these racing sims.

5. Current Tomb Raider I really like these games and I have even finished the first two (haven’t gotten to the third yet, but I will). That’s high praise from someone who rarely gets around to finishing games.

Destiny almost made the cut, but I mostly just played the crap out of the first game and the second fell pretty flat for me. maybe once we see more of these It’ll make the cut. Red Dead Redemption also was my favorite game of last gen and one of the only huge open world games (possibly the only) I have ever finished. Still I haven’t even played the second game so it’s hard to call it a favorite franchise at this point.


#183

No particular order because I’m not sure how many tricks my memory is playing on me and I’m old:

Football Manager
Age of Wonders
Civilization
XCOM (first two old ones and both the Firaxis versions)
Imperialism

I would have put the first two Master of Orions but the third (and the remake) kinda ruins the idea of “best”.


#184

Zelda
Metroid
Metal Gear
Mario
Castlevania

Huh. Thought about it for a while and looks like I came up with a bunch of Nintendo and Konami stuff. Really want to put Street Fighter on there but I can’t take any of these off, each of them has at least a half dozen greats and they’ve all been with me since forever (I didn’t get into SF until later).

I can respect this.


#185

Mario
Civilization
Age of Wonders
Final Fantasy
Sims

Loose criteria, decades of looking forward to new games, lots of gems in the series, ability to move the series forward… even with some missteps. Runner ups: Might and Magic (includes HOMM and MM), Xcom, Europa Univ and Zelda.