I’m going to keep this up to date. Bear in mind that nothing here is certain because nothing can be, but this is meant to show the most likely scenario and resulting possibilities. The first three are as solid as anything can be. The rest are claims or the result of claims. Please add to it or debunk it as you can.
- Scott is the Ravenkeeper (confirmed by his murder)
- Perky is the Washerwoman (confirmed by Scott)
- Rowe is the Empath (confirmed by his murder)
So:
- One of Matt / Lantz is evil (Rowe told us that)
- One of Dave / Matt is evil (Dave accused Matt of being the Imp)
- Casey and Jostly are either both outsiders or both evil, or someone else is Drunk
- If Casey and Jostly are evil then Matt is the third evil