Thanks for the reply and the opportunity to debate :).
Civ 6 test at Toms. $119 i3-8100 time between turns: 14.9 seconds. $519 i7-8086K time between turns: 12.3 seconds.
Multi-core thread-heavy games! was the talk of the town… in 2011. The PS4 and Xbox 1 were on the horizon, and the Xbox 1 ended up shipping with eight cores. Heck, it was the talk of the town in 2006 when the PS3 came out. It’s never happened. Sure there’s a few games… actually there’s not. There’s one game. Ashes of the Singularity, which you and I don’t play. The high core-count has gotten to the point that even the review websites, which have a financial interest in keeping people upgrading, are making comments like “this is silly, unless you’re playing games while recording 4K video and transcoding it to MP4 and uploading it to Twitch and doing other stuff too.”
That was a bit of a rant. In more direct terms, consoles will never have processors that cost more than about $90 which is what an i3 at $120 consumer price works out to, because console prices tend to max out at $400-600 dollars. A new i3 today such as an 8100 will match the next gen consoles.
I do agree that the success of Ryzen has made a big difference. The i3 now a true quad core and is a great improvement.
Most games, like FPS, RPG, and action, which are the dominant AAA type, tend to have a single-thread critical path. Sure extra cores help with some off-path items like physics, but they end up 2-3 FPS faster.
I just searched for the most recent CPU review I could find, which ended up being Tom’s Hardware’s review of the Pentium G56400 (a $64 CPU, being reviewed as a low cost gaming CPU - spolier: it’s fine).
Notice the i3 is at the top of every chart. Also notice what we’re talking about - Far Cry 5 at 102 frames per second. WTF? 102 FPS? I have a 60 Hz IPS monitor and 40-year old eyes. In other words, games will need to get much more graphically impressive to tax that i3 system down to 60Hz.
All of the above said, buying high-end hardware is also fine. A lot of us on this forum are at a point in our lives that we simply want higher-end stuff. That’s ok. Spend your money on things that make you happy. I like the idea of a high end gaming PC, and that 5% difference in turn time in Civ 6 is worth more than 5% cost of parts… I want to maximize my time and not wait for turns. I also have an Oculus Rift - but an i3 and GTX 1070 are also fine for that.