My two cents:
I think the incidents of moderation have increased as the member list has increased because it’s more difficult now to know where people’s tolerance level is.
Not trying to bring up “the good ol’ days,” (if they were that), but I do agree that Qt3 was a kinder, more polite place 6-7 years ago. Does that mean there weren’t flamewars, or that people didn’t get into it? Of course not. But assholes were assholes, and they were equal-opportunity assholes, and with just a few exceptions, battles didn’t drag out for weeks through multiple threads because people just couldn’t let shit go.
I’ve said dumb stuff here, and I’ve been called an idiot for it. But that same person who just called me an idiot for something I said in P&R (there’s a reason I don’t go there anymore) can have a totally reasonable conversation about Dragon Age with me over in the games thread, and I can recount to him a story of what fixed my computer when it was displaying the same symptoms as his were over in hardware.
But the battles were easier to fight, because the community was small enough that we knew what to expect. We knew who could take it and who couldn’t, and what’s more, we knew who was just…like that. It made moderation less necessary, because mostly we kinda kept ourselves and each other in check.
But as the community grows, Tom has to do his best to keep things civil. Sometimes he’s going to be inconsistent, some days he’s just gonna wake up grouchy, and some days he’s gonna make the wrong call. This is still his house, he can do what he wants.
I’ve thrown parties, I’ve had fights break out, and I’ve asked people to leave and discovered later, when I had all the facts, that maybe the OTHER person should’ve been the one I sent home. Shit happens. You don’t like it, don’t come to my parties.
This is Tom’s party, and you guys are free to get pissed off if you want – he is far more tolerant than a lot of people would be – but at the end of the day, he’s the only one who decides who goes, and who stays.
I just hope he doesn’t decide to stop throwing parties.
EDIT: Yes, this was more topical 2 or 3 pages ago, but I wasn’t here to say it then. Basically, I respect all of your opinions, but stop being assholes to Tom, because I like partyin’ here.