Interesting one. The first option is pretty rubbish, but we do get the cylon fleet jumping in as it is (plus a couple of raiders). If we take the second option, we get the cylons arriving with a second basestar. Could make things a bit hairy later.
I don’t have much for the heavies (beyond an ability to shoot straight recently), but I would get a free CAG action. If Boomer can get more shots off she might be a better choice, either for dealing with heavies or the four raiders in 3.