I would just like to say that I just fought two Big Daddies. Simultaneously. And won. On hard.
It wasn’t planned or anything. Only a gibbering splicer would come up with a plan that nutty, obviously. I was trying to snag a Little Sister in Arcadia, and there was sort of an open area with a wide sort of column-thing–with posters and metal plates attached to it–in the center. I was trying to use that to my advantage, in a sort of “All Around the Mulberry Bush” sort of way. I’d circle around to keep the column between us at all times, so I could maintain range but always have some cover to duck behind when I needed to heal up and inject some Eve. I had also just recently spent my entire inventory of junk in a hacked U-Invent machine, making armor-piercing ammo for various weapons, specifically for Big Daddy fights. And I had just bought some grenades. So I was about as well equipped as I could be.
So I’d hit him with an electric shock, and then unload a few grenades at him, and then quickly hit the Plasmid pause-select the instant he’d launch a mine at me, grab TK, and then slide my finger off the pause button right down onto onto the trigger so that I could catch the mine and throw it back at him. That was working pretty well, and I had him down into the red. I ducked behind the column and reloaded the machine gun, and suddenly he appears around the left side of the column (we had been circling it clockwise).
So I was like “Oh, trying to be clever, eh?” and hit him with the now reloaded machine gun. And at that moment I wondered to myself “How in the hell did his health get all the way back up to full?!” And that’s when the Big Daddy that I had actually been fighting appears around the right side of the column. The one that I had just aggroed was a brand new one that had just wandered into the courtyard.
So I really quickly hit the weapon-select pause and held it, and my first thought was “I’m fucked.” Here are two red Big Daddies right in front of me. My strategy is hosed; you can’t play “All Around the Mulberry Bush” with two opponents. Plus, I was starting to get low on armor-piercing ammo, though I still had some grenades left. But then I was like “Why the hell not?” One was already in the red, and I still had six health kits and five Eve hypos. I quickly decided to retreat down the hallway behind me and see if I could get both of them to follow, and then try to spam them both with grenades in the narrower space. I’d have to take a bunch of hits to do it, but I might be able to knock out the hurt one and damage the new one in the process. Then I could stun the remaining one, run past him back to the column, and go back to Plan A.
And somehow, I pulled it off. Two Big Daddies down in one fight, and both of them had Little Sisters in tow. Payday! It’s actually pretty rare that I get through a Big Daddy fight without dying, so this one felt extra satisfying.