This is good timing, as I have some questions about Gloomhaven: JoTL
I played about 35 scenarios of Gloomhaven solo and loved it. The criticism above is definitely real however. With 90 scenarios the thought of finding time to go back and replay a scenario is nauseating. I would fudge plenty of games if they were close, and only replay those that weren’t even close. To compound that, I could never find anyone to play with. Well, that isn’t true, there were people who would be interested in playing, but there was zero chance I was going to get someone to play 90+ scenarios with me. The bulk of my time to play cooperative games like this is a yearly vacation with a friend where we spend 3 days playing a game. Plenty of time to run through Spirit Island a bunch of times, or beat Mechs vs Minions, or Pandemic Legacy. But do I really want to introduce someone to the very complicated game when realistically 3 days gets us to like scenario 15… if that. JoTL sounds like a great solution to that.
But what I love about Gloomhaven is the setting and character progression. Exploring the world, personal goals and retiring characters, permanently improving cards and shopping in the stores, modifying my attack deck, etc.
Strangely, I haven’t been able to find much on this - but how much of the non-dungeon crawling is left?
There are only 4 characters. I understand that you still level them up and improve their attack modifiers… but do you play all 4 characters in the campaign or can you mix and match? Is it reasonable to get any characters to max level?
is it possible to swap in some of the original Gloomhaven characters to JoTL? Or are there cards and scenarios that are dependent on those characters (or balanced for those characters at least)?
You don’t permanently modify cards or unlock new characters - but do you still shop at the store and get new items? Make donations to the temple? I assume the city reputation is gone as well?
Is JoTL meant to be replayed, or is it a once through experience?
25 scenarios in JoTL - about how long would all those take to complete? Is it reasonable to play 2-3 scenarios in a 2 hours sitting? Or do those 25 scenarios translate to 50 hours of gaming?
I ask these questions because I’m looking at games for that aforementioned gaming getaway… and every year I bring a game. My past games look like this:
- Mechs vs Minions
- Spirit Island
- Pandemic Legacy Season 1
All were big winners!
This year i’m looking at
- Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion
- Clank: Acquisitions Incorporated (I’m a huge Clank fan)
- Arkham Horror TCG
- Project Elite
Open to suggestions - we aren’t opposed to complicated and we immerse ourselves in the game for 3 days, with breaks for other games, hiking, and heavy drinking.