Oh yes. I mean the government will collapse no later than fairly soon after Brexit day, with or without a deal.

Unless the DUP decide they hate the deal sufficiently to get rid of the government, I’m not sure I see why.

Any collapse I see happening now is because some Tory rebels have a fit of conscience and realise no-deal Brexit is de-facto government policy, and there is only one way to stop it.

Because the half of the population that is waiting happily for no-deal suddenly realizes it means they can’t buy groceries, and heads roll.

If May passes a backstoppy deal with Labour, the ERG and/or DUP dump her. If she doesn’t pass a deal and Article 50 is revoked, the ERG and maybe even DUP dump her. If she doesn’t pass a deal and we crash out, then we’re going to have the mother of all economic and political crises that no government could survive.

Nobody will realise that until it happens.

Ah, right. I actually think extension/revocation won’t be enough to bring down the government, and I’m not even sure a backstop will mean she’s brought down after the fact. (Though maybe. The DUP might.)

One thing this whole show has taught me is that political parties hold together far more than I realised.

I think a lot of the reason that the ERG has been a paper tiger so far is that they think bringing down the government is (more) likely to stop Brexit. If Brexit is stopped anyway, then that’s not an issue any more. And if they don’t bring down the government at that point, they truly show themselves as a busted flush and they’ll never have any leverage ever again. Maybe they hate Corbyn enough to stomach that, but I don’t think so, at least for the hardcore.

I don’t think extension will bring down the government, BTW, though it’s possible.

But if we’ve left, it’s over. What’s their incentive to bring down the government other than revenge? They’ll lose their leverage entirely when they are unsupported by Tory party HQ in the following GE and lose their seats.

May will not still control Tory party HQ if she supports revocation or referendum.

Well, for a start, from their perspective, if we have a backstop, we haven’t left. But I don’t envisage them standing as Tories in that event unless May is toppled. It’s an SDP scenario.

No, but voting against your government in a Vote of No Confidence is going to get you removed from the party. (And this discussion was not in the scenario where she supports those things, but where she passes a withdrawal agreement with Labour support over the heads of the ERG/DUP/Tory party.)

Well, maybe. May might just stand down at that point and we get a new PM without a GE, so it would have to be more than May they have issue with.

Speaking of May:

That’s a more interesting question.

I also think May would not still control Tory HQ if supported a “Norway plus” BINO.

Some other deal? Maybe. But any deal where Labour demand policy concessions to be enforced by treaty with the EU - even though they had not been demanded by the EU - would be an affront to democracy. I can see it being hard to make that argument cut through with the public though.

I suppose the pithy retort I can offer would be ‘You think May is in control of Tory HQ now?’

Heh. This forum needs emoticons :)

I intend to be in the country around Brexit day time.

So much drama and it’s important.

I ought to be there.

Well, this is one no-deal cliff edge averted:

Hooray!

And maybe another.

In English?

All flights from the UK to Europe won’t be grounded on Brexit day.