I am not a fan of Notre Dame, in fact I actively dislike them but the committee did not put ND into the playoff because of their past rep nor was it a wasted spot. They went undefeated in the regular season, one of only three major universities to do so. How do you justify leaving them out? And who would have been a better choice? Georgia, a 2 loss team? Michigan? A Pac team? Central Florida? They put ND in because they earned the spot and doing anything else would have been flat out stupid. Teams get thumped every year in every playoff. It happens.
I’m aware of the language Richt used in his written statement. He can call it what he likes, but “retirement” seems like something reserved for guys who are fully done with football. This feels more like an Urban Meyer’s retirement from Florida in 2009 right now.
If ND wants to be treated like every other big program team, they need to act like a one. Join a fucking conference and play a fucking conference schedule every year. They already have a built-in recruiting advantage being the premier religious recruiting base in the world, but getting to pick and choose their opposition is just too much. They shouldn’t even be allowed in the NCAA under current conditions imo.
Norte Dame doesn’t have to play a conference championship game like the others which is big to remain undefeated. That also means they don’t go through a conference schedule every year like the rest. I would put say Georgia for example ahead even with two loses since one of those was in the conference title game which again ND doesn’t play and they had the second highest strength of schedule in the FBS. It’s not just about being undefeated.
Lol you list a team like USC shows you just go based off on “names” and have no clue about who they played and their actual quality…you proved my original point perfectly
In this age of black non-Catholic athletes I don’t know that they have a “premier religious” base. BYU probably has an advantage over Notre Dame in that they get often get more mature athletes.
And they actually have a very good schedule on paper this year, it just turned out that several teams had untraditional down years. And ND plays name schools on the road.
However, I would like to see ND join a conference.
While I do not disagree with your rant, it has zero to do with my point which was that under the current system, one for which they actually have provisions for including independent universities, there was no valid argument for excluding ND. It doesn’t matter whether you like it or not, or I like it or not, it is completely moot and not germane to this situation.