Definitely par for the course on L&O. I will expect a miraculous recovery by next week.

I almost gave my TV a standing ovation when she appeared on screen. Fantastic stuff.

Isn’t…

click only if you know the shock ending

“Star Burns” a writer on the show? Maybe he was just finding it too hard to put in the occasional cameo in the show plus his other duties, and he wrote himself out or something similar?

The episode title still escapes me. What in the heck are they talking about?

I did love the episode, though.

Episode Title

Means Dick Wolf. The creator of L&O.

This week more than makes up for the past couple of episodes.

When Michael Ironside walked onscreen, I thought my entire universe was going to implode in a self-referential vortex.

Brilliant, brilliant episode.

Well, that was tremendous. My wife and I went through a binge in the early 00’s where we watched every Law and Order from Season 1 to around where Briscoe left the show. I actually cheered when the coroner showed up. Every little touch was spot on. Also, I totally called who the culprit was when he showed up on screen. How often was it the little guy filing papers or running a small repair shop towards the beginning of an investigation?

Was Dick Wolf’s name the inspiration for the Penny Arcade debacle?

I’d heard a Community regular was going to die this year. Now we know.

That was a really good episode. And best of all, you didn’t need to be a Community fan to enjoy it either. Hopefully they’ll get some positive attention from such an awesome episode.

I disagree with the conventional wisdom that Community has to be more appealing to new viewers in order to succeed. There are plenty of by-the-numbers sitcoms where nothing changes from week to week, the characters never develop, and the plots are standard two-camera fare. Community is a very different show, and maybe it’s too different to stay successful, but I would rather see it fail on its own merits than succeed by trying to be something different.

The writers should make the best show they can come up with, instead of trying to make a show that they think will be appealing to new viewers. I never saw people criticizing Inception or Lost for not appealing to the lowest common denominator.

Community isn’t too advanced; it’s a sitcom on one of the big three networks. People don’t watch it very much because its comedy can be fitful, or only appealing to people who reaaaally like reference and parody.

For some reason I go the opposite way of some of the previous posters… I loved the Civil War one and thought The L&O one sucked. Not sure why, but eh L&O felt like the insight was the same level of what I might have made if I was spoofing the show in a homemade movie I put together with my teenage friends. I’m sure the same could be said for the Civil War one, but that’s just how the two landed for me. I dug the Dean’s “awesome” to the Omar Man’s Gotta Have a Code line, but you had to know Omar was going to say shit from The Wire at some point.

I’m going to blow everyone’s mind.

I enjoyed both the Civil War AND the L&O episodes. And I find Law and Order AND the Civil War themselves incredibly boring!

I loved Civil War, but L&O felt really awkward. For one, L&O spoofs were fun like two decades ago. Today, it’s like making a Cheers spoof now.

Oh man, I would LOVE a Cheers/Seinfeld/Friends spoof!

There are times when I enjoy not getting any of the references on Community, because it means to my eyes the show just appears amazingly varied and full of cool stuff I’ve never seen before.

Seconded.

That’s one of the reasons why the L&O worked for me so much. When they were setting up the premise in the opening minutes, I thought “Oh, no, not a spoof one of these crime shows du jour”. I thought it would be spoofing CSI, NCIS or one of these other ones. But instead, they took it back old school and went to Law and Order, a show I used to really love until I got tired of it. But they really, really captured everything cool and quirky and weird about L&O within that half hour. Just sooooo well done.

I liked Civil war episode, I liked the L&O episode, and being honest, in fact I like 90% of the Community episodes. Their humor falls squarely in the type of humor I love.

I’m “in” for a Cheers or Friends spoof episode.