Elden Ring - George R.R. Martin and Hidetaka Miyazaki

Yeah, I just think people expected less of a souls look/feel, but I’m totally down. I think this looks great. I was very leery about Martin’s involvement, but my fears are allayed (for now).

I’m happy enough with a souls look/feel, but was hoping for something a bit fresh mechanics-wise. Like maybe something a bit different from the save points that respawn enemies, and the fight to get your currency back after death - assuming this game does those, do we know for sure?

As much as I love that stuff I’d like to see From try something really new.

To be fair, it probably would be Dark Souls 4 if Namco Bandai had their way. So, this strikes me as a kind of a compromise in a way. Namco get a sort of Souls-like from From Software whilst Miyazaki and co get to do something fresh that isn’t creatively burdened by being tied to the Dark Souls series.

I just watched the trailer, and while this looks to have Souls-style combat, there were a few notable differences. It looks much less linear corridors, more open-world, especially with having a horse to get around. Speaking of, mounted combat.


And this.

I mean, looking at Miyazaki’s track record and expecting major deviations in core gameplay and overall style is like expecting id software to not make another FPS. This is what his team is good at, but it also looks sufficient different to be interesting. Not that Dark Souls 4 wouldn’t have been sufficiently interesting (I mean, it would only have been the third Dark Souls game, they skipped 2 for some reason).

I’m not sure why this is called Elden Ring and not Dark Souls 4, really.

Disappointment, I was really hoping this would be different from Dark Souls. But it is Dark Souls with a horse and lastgen graphics.

Story wise 2 was actually my favorite.

I think the graphics look pretty good actually.

I think lastgen graphics are perfectly fine. I am still playing even PS3 games, no issues with how they look. The success of the Souls game is not meassured by number of polygons (the games look great).

The interesting part will be, how Fromsoft wii be doing open world design. Dark Souls 1 was an “open world” design, but a small open world. It had limitations (how to get to Anor Londo).

I don’t get the G.R.R. Martin connection (or vibe). So, we can expect that item descriptions, lore and obscure questlines are written by Martin? I hope it was worth it and therefore the caused delay of Winds of Winter…

It sounds like he came up with the backstory for the world. What the elden ring is, how it got broken and so forth, along, presumably, with some of the characters you will kill uh, interact with.

I bet Miyazaki will take the pages and a scissor, cut everything to pieces, draw them from a bag and rearange them in no particular order and paste it on item descriptions. Done! I am good with that approach…

edit: I forgot, he will throw 30 % out

As someone who was not thrilled about Martin’s involvement, I am actually fine with it, too, because the alluded to but never shown (at least as far as I made it) fight with the seven royal guards or whoever they were and Stark’s buddies from which only he and his lowborn crossbowman emerged alive was one of the more memorable things from A Song of Etc, so I think he could come up with a nicely textured canvas on which From can paint.

Which means I will be able to play it on my daughters PS4 and not have to spend $$$ on a new PC.

Sounds like it’s win/win!

Yea, I am reading that in some places. But imagine the shitstorm if it had looked completely different, like Fallout or something. The same people would be bitching. Frankly, some people just like to bitch.

Is this a MMO or single player?

It will hopefully be both, if it’s like the Souls games. Single player, but players leaving messages to help you, or fool you, and laying down support for bringing in cooperative players, and certain other players invading you.

No news on that front as far as I know though.

They’ve confirmed it offers co-op. Not an MMO, though.