I think a big part of it was the game (Elite in the 80’s) and it’s two rather brilliant creators (Sir David Braben and Ian Bell) and how it came about. If you like the DNA of Elite was incredibly strong, and even if in the rather top-publisher-heavy video game industry of the late 90’s into the 2000’s, that meant for David it was still a contender.
I mean what is not to love about being a free wheel that inherits a space ship in an actual galaxy sized game ‘world’, set in a reasonably recognizable human future?
So yeah, while the publishers pretty much killed it off for a good decade or so (and in the case of Elite, with both Frontier and FFE, it could be argued the publishers nearly killed those games too, releasing them as buggy as they were, FFE in particular!), Elite was (is) such a great seed idea, with pretty damn awesome delivery for the various era’s it had it’s three previous parts released in.
Wing Commander, like the X-wings games, that were also the cream of the crop for ages and awesome games (and obviously you have likes of Freelancer and Independence War in this timeline), nothing was such a large a scope in terms of having an actual galaxy to play around in. Elite was serious brain candy for many uk youths for oh so long.
Now obviously i’ve been a bit of a critic of Elite: Dangerous since it’s release, but that is mostly born out of my love of the game, knowing where it has been and where it could go…
So yeah, i’m a hopeless Elite romantic with my fingers dirty from hex editing the reverse engineered third game (FFE), because i’ve always loved it since 1984 when i first played it on my friends BBC Micro. And even if i currently find Elite: Dangerous lacking, i know that strong game DNA it comes from will eventually get it’s time to shine, so it was a no brainer for me personally to back the kickstarter for the long haul and get the all expansion pass.
Now it might blow up in my face, there are certainly many things we have seen from Frontier (the dev) and Elite: Dangerous so far that could kind of hint that might have diluted that DNA down the passage of years, we shall see.
As long as i get to land on Earth at some point, and gaze up at Mars low on the horizon after dusk, and seamlessly jump in my ship and fly there to buy Liquor to sell on the planet New California in Epsilon Eridani, while enjoying a small holiday with my crew on it’s azure beaches, then i’ll be happy, and fully on board with Elite: Dangerous :)