Leaving aside the (totally justified) criticisms of this game, I am somewhat bemused to still see, lo these many years later, so many people lamenting the latest Fallout game as “not really Fallout.” I mean, yeah, the original (I think I reviewed it when it came out, but I may have just played the hell out of it, can’t recall) was a great RPG, despite the time limit thing (eventually removed I think), and Fallout 2 was MOTS but better. And yes, the shift in FO 3 to a first-person, more action-y experience was jarring, even for those who really ended up loving it.
I’m guessing the folks who have been grumpy about the franchise since FO 3’s launch are really invested in the traditional RPG aspects of the series? I love me some turn-based tactical combat in RPGs, and loot and progression and stats are always welcome, but I also love FPS mechanics, first-person world exploration, and all that. For me, Fallout was always mostly about the neat conceit they had, the retro-futuristic post-apocalyptic setting that made no real sense but was somehow wicked cool. I loved the turn-based mechanics and traditional RPG elements of the first two games, but they were not, to me, central to the idea of Fallout. And the storylines and even the basic setting, in terms of specific lore and such, were always wonky and ultimately kind of disposable.
So when I’m still, in 2018, seeing people say “I like Fallout but isn’t Fallout,” it makes me think that people are wanting a game that, to be blunt, is never going to be made, period. I get that, once having established a “standard” or meta for a particular game setting, one can reasonably expect each successive game to have some strong ties to that standard, but it also seems to me that standards and metas will evolve. I certainly agree that FO 4 and '76 moved far from the original system framework of the original games, and even from FO 3 (NV, hmm, I’m on the fence there). By now, though, I would have thought folks would have realized that you can’t go home again, and if there’s no there, there, with the new games, that isn’t going to change.