It is World of Warcraft!
Funny story. I was casting about for a box to pick, and I happen to have this box on my shelf. Not wanting to go through the effort of taking a picture of it, I look on moby games... and the cover has an Elf, not an Orc. The German cover has an Orc, but my cover is in English. So it turns out that the Orc cover is actually somewhat unusual, and collectors actually want it. Some guy is trying to sell his on ebay for $90! Crazy what the Box Art Challenge can teach you.