Finished Seasons 1-3 with my 17-yr-old daughter tonight, my second time through and her first.
When her mom (who is also in love with the show) discovered a few weeks ago that we were watching it together (better to beg for forgiveness than to ask for permission situation) she protested at first, but her main complaints were about nudity and sex, elements which I don’t feel stand out especially in this show – not any more than other shows these days, at any rate – and the idea of a father and his daughter watching such scenes together was her biggest issue. But my kid is well seasoned, and she didn’t even flinch during those scenes. She’s mature enough now to handle it and we have a system that works: we don’t look at each other or interact in any way when a TV or movie scene gets sexy, and it all works out.
And the violence, well she and I have watched lots of shows and movies that had more violence. Supernatural, for instance (which we love) could be said to be even darker, more violent and more gory at times. Really, the most challenging aspects of GoT for my daughter were the Theon torture scenes. And those she was ready for, because I’d watched GoT before and I’d given her a synopsis, and we’d agreed on a plan. She saw just enough to understand who Ramsay Snow was and what sort of trickery he was up to and didn’t have to witness much or any torture, and we skipped through most of that material. (I also explained to her that it’s generally considered to be one of the weaker parts of the show and book series.) She said, as I’d anticipated, that the hardest part for her was feeling sad for the victim, which rings true for me, with torture scenes. She was also prepped for the Red Wedding scene and missed the gory details, thanks to her Shield of Fingers (no skipping) and didn’t lose a sense of the plot and story changes there.
We enjoy the same favorite character arcs/interplays: Arya and the Hound, Jamie and Brienne, Daenerys and everyone around her, Jon Snow with various characters, Tyrion with various characters. And it was a proud moment for me when she detected that Maester Pycelle, fairly early on, was not nearly as week and feeble as he wanted others to think he was.
We finished it up with the two trailers linked in this thread, and that cemented her love for the show, although she was already lamenting the long wait that was in store for her. I wish I’d started watching with her a few weeks later, because April 6 can’t come soon enough. We’ll probably have to start True Detectives next.
Edit: Added some positives, TD.