Grognard Wargamer Thread!

I dunno. I’ve never heard about those extreme fascist hunters, and that sounds pretty counterproductive. But I get not wanting to play the bad guys. I don’t know that I’ve ever played as the Germans in a WWII computer game where you have a choice. (Similarly I rarely play the bad guys in fantasy games.)

On the other hand, if you’re a serious wargamer (I’m not) in a regular group (I’m not), then switching it up seems like common courtesy.

There’s a big difference between avoiding stuff to which you have a strong adverse relationship–family history, for instance, or personal experience–and simply being a wannabe tool. I’ve played with people who glorified both the Nazis and those who were apologists for Stalin, and I liked neither group very much. In general, my interest in historical wargaming has always been about the tactical and strategic conundrums that come up, and the ability to sort of see a version of what happened, or at least the challenges that were faced, play out before me. If the subject matter of a game was too close for comfort, I just wouldn’t play it.

Of course, there were also the folks who were just weird, like the former armored cav guy who believed in aliens and kept predicting the end of the world…

What a show…

Here we go…

Seriously, my favorite part of that awesome movie.

Yeah, its actually fairly deep on the history in the lyrics too…while being freaking hilarious. Great film. Kinda gets lost sometimes among all his other great works.

Whenever the age old “Nazis and Commies in wargaming” horse gets exhumed to be ceremonially rebeaten again before being reburied I always have this pop into my head:

I think it gets exhumed, as you put it, because it never really died. Since the beginning of board wargaming the hobby has wrestled with its image. Sometimes the obloquy hurled at wargamers was unjustified, and the product of utter ignorance. Sometimes, there was fire to go with the smoke. I think one of the issues with WWII games, for example, is that the seemingly logical approach that most wargamers take, which is to separate the politics from the military history stuff, really is an attempt to what really can’t be done. Yes, you can carve off specific areas to focus on and leave other areas out, as long as the focus is narrow and the time frame is short. But ultimately, it all is of a piece, and you can’t fundamentally understand the battlefield performance of armies without considering the social, military, economic, and political context within which they operate. Unfortunately, for WWII, this brings people into areas where too many folks simply aren’t willing to do the heavy lifting necessary to compartmentalize when necessary without losing sight of the big picture. Too many want to oversimplify things one way or the other, and in my experience, the Nazi fanbois are by far the most numerous of these offenders.

I think it gets exhumed because people wanna make the same points they did the last time. :). And the time before that. Recursion!

Not sure if this is mentioned above somewhere but Compass Games is having their holiday sale until the end of the month. Use the code HOLIDAY19 to get 25-30% off. Not sure they have anything I can’t live without. Decisions, decisions…

Until they get an errata-free, unbroken design out the door, beware my friend.

OK, thanks. So even something like Bitter Woods or Enemy Action Ardennes are suspect?

IDK, but with those specific titles, I’d search around BGG first and see what the vox populi are saying regarding a title. Their track record is so bad, that with them that would be my first step if I was getting a Compass title.

Good idea. Thanks.

Bitter Woods I don’t know about the Compass Edition (I only have the AH version). Enemy Action Ardennes is fine.

Thanks Brooski. I mean, you can never have too many Bulge games right? :)


I wrote this up.

Nice writeup @Brooski. Don’t feel bad, I’m sure even some of the greatest generals in history couldn’t do first grade math either. :P

Sorry, been busy with guests for a few days. How about this:

Absolutely awesome. Thank you!