Updated Impressions:
Ok, I’ve had a few hours to sit with it and play around a bit. I have mixed feelings so far. I havent found a way to slow down time, and with the waters being completely packed with ships of all sort, its really hard for me to keep track of all the goings on. Pirates sacking this city or this ship, this nation doing this to this other nation, all in super speed time kinda makes me feel hectic and rushed. Perhaps its better I break it down by gameplay:
Overhead Sailing Map - Lots of ships going to and fro, very open ended, battles raging all over, real nice atmosphere, really makes the game feel alive. However it suffers from having a little too much activity however, I think in a patch perhaps, they should lower the ship count a bit, I mean sometimes it’s shoulder to shoulder with ships on the screen.
Ship Battles - pretty damn cool, by far the most fun I’ve had in the game so far. It’s fun to try and shoot ships from a long distance to test your skill. I do have one big concern though, at any time you can charge your ship up and board the other ship, what’s the point of even waisting ammo shooting at it?
Dueling/Fencing - cool in that Monkey Island kinda way, however, just like Monkey Island, the novelty is almost completely gone after about 2 or 3 fights. Wish there was more I could say about it, but it comes down to being just another hand-eye coordination mini-game.
Land Fighting - This is the one that really gets me cause I was looking very much forward to it… It feels like it coulda been so much more if it had just been a little deeper, as it stands, its pretty cool, but after sacking some towns, I was already hoping for a auto-resolve button I cant seem to find :) Bucaneers shoot, pirates rape, officers = uber. Simple formula, but there are some nice little twists like natives deciding to help you out or such.
Jail/Sneaking - Hard to say about this one, pretty emmm boring… It’s kinda cool at first , but it got old quick. At this point if I lose a ship battle, I’m just reloading a save game.
Dancing - Sorry to say, but it’s pretty gay to me. It will be fun for those people who like hand/eye coordination mini-games or DDR, but it just seriously annoyed me…
Economics - After sacking a couple of treasure and merchant ships, I found myself with a vast amount of gold that I used to just mindlessly upgrade my ship with all I could. I hate to say it, but perhaps I should try on a harder difficulty (was playing on the 3rd difficulty I believe), cause as it stands, upgrades and money just come way too quick and easy, which really ruins the mood for me.
This game is good… no doubt, but from my first few hours playing it, this’ll be something I get into when I have nothing else to play. However I went back to playing Vampire Bloodlines now, and soon to be KOTOR 2 in December.