Have we talked about Doodle God? Not Doodle Jump, or Pocket God. Let’s talk about Doodle God. (iTunes link)
First off, you can play most of it online for free anyway. Here it is on armorgames, I think it’s on newgrounds and all those flash game sites too. So yeah, big incentive right off to not bother paying a dollar for it.
Next up, it shouldn’t be that fun. You start with icons for four elements, earth, fire, air, water. Then you just combine them to make things. Fire + Earth = Lava. Then combine the results to make things. That’s it, that’s the game. Trial and error and logic that often only applies in retrospect. Lava + Water = Steam and Stone. Stone + Fire = Metal. So far so good, but it gets more abstract as your options expand. It keeps them in categories, occasionally introducing new categories for your discoveries, and so on.
There’s a hint system that will either show you a result you don’t have yet (leaving you to try to figure out what available elements would combine for it) or showing you two categories, indicating that you’ve still got some undiscovered combination among the given elements. It’s got a cooldown timer so you can’t just spam the hints though. You can quit and relaunch the game to get a new hint right away, but that’s just enough work that you won’t feel like abusing it too often.
But you will want the hints. Otherwise (and even with them), there is a lot of trial and error. Lots of brute force combining, looking for results. Lots of “Come on, why doesn’t that work?!”
So why do I keep playing it? I don’t know. Couldn’t really tell you, but I kept coming back to it throughout the day a few minutes after every “ragequit” when I couldn’t figure anything out. Certainly there is some satisfaction in some clever results. You’ll probably crack a smile when Ship + Alcoholic = Pirate. It just doesn’t seem like the occasional grin would be worth the trial and error and error and error, but here I am recommending it.
There are “Extras” that I haven’t unlocked, so I don’t know what’s involved, but barring those being amazing, I don’t know why I’d ever play through this more than once. But again, somehow it all works, and my dollar is totally justified. Certainly better than that dollar I spent on Vanitas!
Try the Flash version and see what you think, nothing to lose there. As far as I can tell, the difference is that the iPhone version has 196 elements to unlock compared to the Flash version’s 115, and the iPhone version has some extra/annoying commentary (that you can turn off).