Grr. The problem is that I’d have to actually compute what each of their spells deals at the end of the game.
I’m going to go with Tibbers only AoE’ing one player with his faux-Sunfire, but I don’t think that’d make that much of a difference. I will, however, give Ryze two hits of Spell Flux, and I’ll calculate the damage if he’s hitting multiple people with his ult up separately.
We’re going to assume that they both have 40% CDR total. I think this is a viable assumption.
Annie’s got:
Disintegrate - 2.4s, 245 + .7 AP
Incinerate - 4.8s, 280 + .75 AP
Tibbers - 450 + .7 AP
Tibbers AoE - 1s, 35 + .2 AP
She bursts 975 + 2.15/AP instantly, and then does a sustained 195 + .448/AP DPS afterwards (putting out two Qs and one W every 4.8 seconds).
Ryze has:
Overload - 2.1s, 140 + .2 AP + .08 max mana
Rune Prison - 9.4s, 200 + .6 AP + .05 max mana
Spell Flux - 9.4s, 130 + .35 AP
Desperate Power
Every time Ryze casts a spell, the time remaining on a spell goes down by a second, So casting Overload, followed by Rune Prison, puts him on a 1.1 second CD for Overload.
Thus, to cast QWQRQEQ takes him less than five seconds (we’ll say five seconds anyway).
His W is now on a 4 second cooldown. Waiting 2 more seconds allows him to Q again and then to enact the combo all over again 1 second later, so Ryze’s sustained combo might go like so:
QWQEQRQ[5 seconds] [2 seconds] QWQEQ[4.5 seconds]
This takes Ryze 11.5 seconds, which is a pretty sizable teamfight / team brawl.
In that 11.5 seconds, Ryze deals:
Q x 7 for 980 + 1.4/AP + .56 max mana
Wx2 for 400 + 1.2/AP + .1 max mana
Ex4 for 520 + 1.4/AP
Total of 1900 + 4/AP + .66 max mana over 11.5 seconds, not counting Desperate Power AoE.
Annie deals 3,217 + 7.302/AP over 11.5 seconds, not counting her AoE.
The math doesn’t look good for Ryze, nosir. I might have to agree with you after all. :)
But first I’ll have to actually figure out how much AP an endgame Annie would have and how much AP and mana an endgame Ryze would have… anyone know of a place for that offhand?