Thanks for the suggestions. The closest to what I was looking for Pirates! or Mount & Blade. Factions on a map (doesn’t have to be super big, in fact smaller is probably better) that interact, wage war and capture territory with and without the player.
I lot of games have factions interacting narratively, but not implemented as a game system.
Sorry if my demand is too specific. :P
I love Horizon’s Gate (see next post, my recommendation from another thread). The exploration is satisfying and I like the combat and class design. The factions are very static though and while the great patch support added some notable map impact with outposts and harbour management it’s still a bit static.
I-War 2 is a space sim with a campaign, right? No open world, no factions on a map? I only know it from reading about it, and it having Newtonian spaceflight IIRC.
Do the factions in Phoenix Point actually act on their own? Do havens ever change hands (also with the aliens) or do they just get raided/destroyed? I can actually see the game being a good baseline for the “factions with the player tipping the scales” gameplay I was looking for, but don’t remember the base version of Phoenix Point really utilizing that direction at all.
I was really looking forward to Vagrus. I made the thread in this forum about it too. I was very disappointed with the actual game though for a whole bunch of reasons. I haven’t tried recently but the factions in that one are completely static still, right? Locations are story locations not interactables in a strategic approach.
Endless Sky & Escape Velocity do fit the open world part. But they don’t have an interactable/changable map. All faction interaction is story/quest related, not mechanical IIRC.
Starsector does have a lot of promise and a bunch of neat ideas but it doesn’t come together at all in enjoyable gameplay for me. Individual systems like the space combat, colony and player-faction management, the factions procedurally fighting/conquering each other are interesting, but they absolutely clash with each other and every other game system they touch. The whole thing just doesn’t come together.
I do remember liking the official Pirates remake and it is specifically what I asked for… hmm.