With the season winding down, I find myself wondering what the Mariners end up doing in the offseason. A lot of money drops off the books, meaning they could legitimately go after a big name free agent. But will they? Perhaps, but not necessarily where we thought they would a few months ago.
Only a few positions are firm when it comes to the field and batting order. Dustin Ackley has been everything expected at 2B. Brendan Ryan is going to be back at SS. And for now we have to assume Ichiro is once again a lock in RF. But the rest is up in the air.
Miguel Olivo is signed for another year at catcher, but they need some plan their that involves him as the backup and not the regular starter. The teams best prospect at the position is Adam Moore, but he’s been injured most of the last two seasons and hasn’t hit when he has been healthy. Do they go outside for someone else?
Third base is interesting as well. It’s pretty clear they’ve given up on Figgins. Ackley’s college teammate Kyle Seager seems likely to get the first shot as he’s played pretty solid ball since his second call-up.
The outfield seems a logjam at this point. Franklin Gutierrez has regressed, but has potential. The two outfielders picked up at the deadline, Casper Wells and Travon Robinson, have both shown they can play. And then there are organizational candidates like Carlos Peguero (struggled in a long look this year) and Michael Saunders (struggled in a long look last year and early this season). Have they given up on those guys? And DH doesn’t seem like it can easily just act as the overflow, with other options.
Which leads to first base and DH. Justin Smoak got off to a good start, struggled for a couple of months, and now seems righted again. But he’s not going to end up with the kind of solid .250/20/80 kind of line everyone hoped. And yet he still has an OPS+ over 100. And then there is Mike Carp, a veteran minor leaguer who finally produced when he was brought up largely by default and currently holds the second highest OPS+ on the team. Where does he fit in?
And the pitching is pretty well set for next year as well. Hernandez, Pineda, Vargas, and Beavan can largely be written into the rotation right now. And plenty of internal options for that fifth spot (though the prospects tried so far have struggled.)
Which raises the question of whether the long assumed pursuit of Prince Fielder will even end up happening. Throw him in as a 1b/DH, and suddenly Carp or Smoak are displaced. Carp can play a corner outfielder, but Smoak is pretty limited. And Carp to the outfield increases the logjam.
So maybe they spend their money elsewhere, though where doesn’t seem so obvious (other then maybe catcher, where there isn’t a great free agent anyway). So this team needs an instant upgrade on offense and yet finds itself with plenty of apparent options already in just about every spot.
Which is why this offseason will be incredibly important for the team.