As far as looking better than HL2 or Doom 3, I’d say that while it’s at least close to as good looking, that’s made largely irrelevant when you realize it’s just a much better game entirely. I could see a case for HL2 looking better than Riddick because of the different environments it has, but really, Riddick is so much more fun than either game it doesn’t matter.
Also, should we start a separate one for Xbox and PS2? I would also recommend a Gamecube thread, but I haven’t seen Dave Long around in a while, so there might not be enough material for that one.
I wasn’t going to click on it, because I thought it might go to some Freddie Prinze Jr. fansite, but it seems the list Jose linked is confined to the games that scored in the 8-9 range of the 7-9 scale.
The 8.3 to 9.7 scale to be precise, reaching all the way back to 1998.
There aren’t any truly bad games on the list, but if someone asks me today which games they should play, Caesar III is not going to be one of my first picks.
I should contribute here, though, and echo the recommendation of Rome: Total War. Sims 2 is also a must play in my book.
Wow…I’m just gonna have to disagree with Troy, in that I don’t care what day it is…I’d pick Caesar III over The Sims 2 any day of the week.
I enjoyed the Sims, but the Sims 2 just seemed…hollow, to me.
I mean to each his own. And I guess this isn’t entirely relavent. I was just surprised to see Troy (of all people!) to say “poo” to Caesar III, and then in the same post, call Sims 2 a must-play.
Hey now. I didn’t say poo. Don’t you go putting words in my mouth.
I loved Caesar III, but it is very much of its day and if someone is just getting back into PC Gaming, I’m certainly not recommend a game eight years old. If I was going to send them to a city builder it would be to Children of the Nile.
And I still have immaculate taste. Don’t make sic the undead wumpus on you.
Obviously, because you did send me to that very game recently. Thanks, by the way. It didn’t hold my attention as long as I’d hoped, but that’s no failing of the game…Even Tropico (which I used to absolutely adore) hasn’t been cutting it for me lately, so I think I’m just not in a city-builder phase in my life. :-)
Anyway, so that I make a vague contribution to this thread: I recommend Vampire - The Masquerade: Bloodlines. A lot. Grabbed on recommendation of these guys, and it’s the best RPG – or, for that matter, best game – I’ve played in awhile.