Yeah, I mean, I didn’t at all follow the discussion leading up to this; I just got tagged on TTRPG shit. Virtually every Computer or Console RPG I’ve ever seen is absolutely shit as an actual roleplaying game; at best they’re branching storyteller machines awkwardly bolted onto an overly complicated tactical engine. But, well, for better or worse, that’s what CRPGs, JRPGs, etc., are and have been since time immemorial, and until we get functional AI that can GM half as well as a human, it’s the best we’ll manage, and it’s still a far cry from an RTS.
Maybe Dungeon Siege came close, insofar as you could basically play it like a fantasy-skinned Ground Control.