More spoilers for this episode Aleck, get out of this thread until you listen to it.
So Jay took the cops to the victim’s car. That does lend credibility to his story, right? He can’t just be making the whole thing up to get Adnan in trouble.
Let’s say for a second that Adnan is not the murderer. Then what has to be true? That the anonymous caller had to have it in for Adnan? That Jay had to be making up all the shit about what Adnan said and meeting at Best Buy and driving around smoking joints afterward. But Jay also has to at least know where the victim’s car was. Maybe he or someone he knew found it and then concocted this whole story to get Adnan in trouble? But wasn’t one of inconsistencies when he told his girlfriend Jen about assisting with disposing the body? If he just found the car afterward, he would have to find it that same day to concoct the story to frame Adnan.
So that just leads me to the conclusion that either Adnan really did it, or if he didn’t, then Jay probably knows who did, which is why he knew where the victim’s car was. Is it possible that Jay is the murderer? I see no motive there though, so I don’t like that possibility.
I gotta say, this is not looking good for Adnan. With the lack of any other viable suspect, it always comes back to him.
One other thing: didn’t they say in the first episode that the key time Adnan had to account for was like 33 minutes or something? And that the alibi in the library possibly accounted for that time? But even if it didn’t, Jay’s story seems to be a whole lot longer than an hour or so. Adnan had to meet her, strangle her, put her in the trunk, have Jay show up, show him her body in the trunk, drive to leakin’ park, take her body to the spot by the tree trunk, dig a shallow grave, bury the body, go back to the car, hang out and drive around smoking weed, and then get dropped off. Sounds like he would have to have much more than an hour unaccounted for if Jay’s story is to be believed.