solomani,
Yes I have played both, and pretty much every MMORPG since Meridian 59 :shock:
I played COH until the end of the 1st free month, and I found the core gameplay to be very enjoyable, however I can’t really explain it, but I found after time I really had no attachment to my character.
I identified with my character as much as I would the marine in the doom series, or Mario in the Nitendo games. Initial character creating was a hoot, but advancing your character with the little ability “pills” just didn’t do it for me. COH seemed to me just like a regular console game that you play now and then for the sheer fun of it. For me, I never “felt” like a hero inhabiting a world. For many that is not a problem, but I like RPG’s that make me feel that I am someone else, somewhere else.
I recently stopped playing Everquest, and I played that game off and on since the beginning, but I never got anywhere near the “end game”. Everquest had a great deal of history and lore, but it really wasn’t attached to the gameplay. You could find it if you wanted. My impression of Everquest was that you created a character, and then immediately started whacking rats and bats outside Freeport…then moved on to the commonlands…then Kurn’s Tower…and so on and so on. For me there was never any satisfaction to be had at your current level. You were ALWAYS looking at the experience bar creep up slower and slower as you develped your character.
I think EQ2 is so immersive because it:
Gives you reason to be there.
Gives you , a meaningful starting base of operations
Breeds loyallty to your home city and makes you feel good to be Evil :twisted: (For Freeport anyway).
Once citizen ship is established gives you some guidelines as how to proceed, but gives you the freedom to choose how you do so.
It does all these very sublty, and draws you in resulting in that “gaming smile” where you suddenly realize that your hooked. Freaking Brilliant.