My choice would be Star Wars Empire at war since, not only can you pause battles, but the entire game speed is configurable and you can slow it right down to suit your pace. It also helps that the game itself is damn fun, offering you far more than just an RTS. You’re also looking at less of a requirement for the keyboard since each unit only has one power, where as Rise of Legends has heroes (which if Warcraft III is anything to judge by will need serious micro-management and keyboard skills). Battle for Middle-Earth and its sequel have formations, unit powers, upgrades etc. Dawn of War is simply keyboard mad, the battles are fast paced and a mouse alone won’t be enough, not if you want to play every side. They all have different movement types. In terms of the keyboard requirement I’d say SWEW has the least need for one.
Rise of Legends I have no experience of. I loaded the demo, but the garish interface and the fact that it dumped me in campaign 2, put me off. I intend to come back to it and give it another chance, but SWEW and Kohan 2 are vying for my demo gaming attention.
I loved Battle for Middle-Earth, especially the way it was so different from other RTS games, making you go out and capture points, making sieges a big part of the game by starting you with walls, having cavalry which felt like cavalry. It was an awesome game, though coupled with the usual EA AI which can’t play for crap. Having just played the demo of Kohan 2 I can say that they are surprisingly similar in many ways. It was the first RTS since Warcraft III to get me online, but unfortunately the Gamespy matchmaking system throws random NAT tantrums, and thus was I forced back to Battle.net. I had the same experience playing Dawn of War online. Unfortunately, if you’re going to play this single-player only, maybe not, the campaign is nothing special, and the AI brain-dead.
Battle for Middle-Earth 2 suffers from “just another RTS” syndrome. It has a couple of elements carried over from the first one, but really if you like BFME2 the chances are you’ll like any other big name RTS, and others have done it better. The only reason to play this is if you are a fan of the license, or for War of the Ring mode, which to me looks inferior to Galactic Conquest in SWEW. Still, it’s more depth than mere skirmish.
Dawn of War is damn solid fun to play, and the AI will actually put up a fight. You have a good variety of races, all of them different. Unfortunately, the game system (which I think excellent) is crippled by truly asstastic map design which takes what should be a free flowing game, and turns it into the usual Warcraft III “two big armies” game. I still play it because I love the racial variety, but IMO Relic messed up the map design, and the game balance is pretty awful and despite regular patches. Relic don’t seem able to sort it out, and I’ve heard that since Winter Assault its turned into a bit of a tech race. A shame, the support is there but they appear unable to balance the game, yet soon we’ll see another two races. I sometimes wonder if the plan is to add races faster than people can exploit them. There’s a fan-made AI out there, but last I saw the official AI would spank it, and the design team seem more interested in making an “interesting” AI than a good one, so I’d avoid it.
The campaigns are dull, but the skirmish AI quite good. Unfortunatly, for reasons beyond my understanding, if you play on Hard down (the AI takes an economic hit) in a team game, the game holds your teammates back if you’re doing too well. Why it would do this on the easier levels is… God knows. Anyway, campaign average, skirmish fun!
Since you’ve already got the BFME games, try those. They’re so different from one another you’ll likely enjoy one of them, and BFME at least was starting to become balanced the last I saw. I don’t have the same experience of the AI from BFME2, so it might be better, but it demands more piddling about because building is now handled like “any other” RTS.
Star Wars Empire at War has a demo available which gives you a good taste of the game. It was enough to get my order the second I quit, a refreshingly different experience. The AI was even fun to fight against! I think, with its configurable speed, ability to pause and entertaining AI (from my experiences and Impressions on Octopus Overlords) that this would be your best bet. You of course get Galactic Conquest which gives you a 4X-lite element on top of the space and land battles, and there’s also skirmish modes.
Dawn of War has excellent scope thanks to its five races (with Winter Assault), and team games look spectacular. Unfortunately once you delve further into it you find a distinctly shallow balance. Fun to play, but sometimes I think it’s more fun to watch a huge team replay and just enjoy the animations.
My FUN ranking:
- Star Wars Empire at War (based on demo only)
- Battle for Middle-Earth
- Dawn of War
- Battle for Middle-Earth 2 (based on demo only)
My SP ranking:
- Star Wars Empire at War (based on demo only)
- Battle for Middle-Earth 2 (based on demo only)
- Dawn of War
- Battle for Middle-Earth
My keyboard (not needed) ranking:
- Star Wars Empire at War (based on demo only)
- Battle for Middle-Earth
- Battle for Middle-Earth 2 (based on demo only)
- Dawn of War