Pizza continues to be a popular subject in the family kitchen. We’ve tried a few different recipes for dough, and have one we like for the oven, but it still definitely has a character distinct from pizzeria pizza.
Now that spring has finally arrived in western PA, though, we can get closer, with pizza on the grill. I don’t know if it’s this dough recipe, or if it’s just that a grill more closely approaches a commercial pizza oven, but this is consistently the best pizza I’m able to make. Recipe courtesy a local mommy blogger.
Grill Pizza
2 tsp (or 1 packet) active dry yeast
1.25 cups warm water
4.25 cups flour
2 tsp salt
0.25 cup olive oil
Stir yeast into water. Let sit for 15 minutes.
Mix the flour and salt together. Either in a mixer with a dough hook, or in a large bowl, slowly add water and oil in turns. Knead (with dough hook or on a floured surface) until smooth, adding flour by tablespoons if it feels slimy, or water by tablespoons if it feels gritty. It ought to end up smooth and slightly sticky.
Put the dough in an oiled bowl under a damp dish towel, and let it rise until doubled in size. (About an hour.)
Punch down the dough and divide into eight evenly-sized pieces. Roll out with a rolling pin to ~1/4" thickness. (They’ll be personal-size. Divide into fewer pieces for larger pizzas, but those are harder to fit on the grill, and less fun to make.)
Heat your grill to medium. Brush one side of each pizza with olive oil, and place it oiled side down on the grill. Close the lid for a few minutes, and pull it off when the downward side is starting to brown.
Oil the uncooked side, then flip the pizza over and add sauce and toppings to the cooked side. Return to the grill and close the lid, cooking until done.
Pizzas on the stone in the oven, in my experience, rarely have the pizzeria-style droop, where a slice will have a thin crust beneath the toppings which is flexible enough to bend, but still a little crispy around the edges. They’re either bready and stiff, or crispy and stiff. This recipe gets closer to the pizza shop ideal than any other ones I’ve made.