This is easily 800+ more square feet than almost any other house in this price range so far (mostly due to the finished basement, I expect). Though there have been a couple decently priced 1600-ish ones, but one's below market price due to being held by a community land trust, and the other sold real fast. I strongly suspect it's failed to sell so far because it has no garage and the layout is a bit weird. And if you have a car here, you really want a garage. I don't own a car, though, and have no desire to.
It still seems like a heck of a deal so I'm paranoid something terrible is going to turn up in the inspection.