Wow, that was a very strange guess, it felt right, but I thought it couldn’t be so… (I knew it were SNES sprites, though…)
I’ll post something tomorrow!
[Oops, missed the last page.]
Weird. I couldn’t have guessed it, but I was literally just thinking of using Actraiser as my next choice if I won.
No need to bump, just post something to start the game up again!
Ok, here it goes. Sorry about this, I totally forgot (elections happenign here and all that…)
Let’s see how long this lasts…

Well, it has lasted 24 hours, so I think we need another clue.
It looks damn familiar, though.
CraigM
2664
Just for kicks, a probably horribly wrong guess, but it seems like an RTS or MOBA icon:
League of Legends
Yeah, it’s way to tiny for me to even have a guess. Could be almost anything. It looks kinda like a keyhole maybe. Darksiders?
Otagan
2666
Pretty sure it’s a spider facing downward but haven’t the slightest what it’s from. Need more context.
Yeah, looks like a neon-y spider thing, possibly from a twin-stick shooter or something?
To be boring, I’ll guess Ultimate Spiderman.
I’ve got nothing. Depths of Peril?