Why do rivalries matter?
Because as a Bears fan I had an interesting game to watch yesterday. Bears are in, sealed, and done – #2 seed, win or lose. Might as well sit the first string and tank the game, right?
Well, no. Because the last game is against the Packers. The Packers, dammit, and not only do the Bears get the week 17 chance to beat them and sweep the division, but doing so will also keep them from the playoffs, and how sweet would that taste?
Granted, it didn’t happen, but there was an interesting, meaningful game to watch because of division scheduling. DERP DERP HI I’M A MOUTH BREATHER. If the Bears had played, oh, I dunno… Jacksonville… would it have been worth watching? Probably not.
But, I see that we’ve already backtracked on allowing division scheduling. Still holding onto the straight seeding idea, because it’s “more fair”? Once you allow division scheduling, I’d argue that no, it’s not.
The NFC South is the only division with three teams that scored 10 wins this year. Coincidentally, all three teams not only had the horrible Panthers to beat up on twice… but the NFC Souths’ 2010 intraconference rival division was the West – every single one of those teams got to beat up on each of the shit-show NFC West teams, as well.
Would it be fair, under a straight “six best” seeding this way, that New Orleans could get in with 11-5 on a soft, soft schedule and eliminate one of the 10-6 teams who played non-powerdpuff rotation divisions (Green Bay, who played the NFC East and AFC East, and New York, who played the NFC North and AFC South)?
Yeah, I suspect not.
If you’re going to make the concession to keep division play alive a straight-seed tournament is no more fair than division winners plus two wildcards – and arguably more unfair.
Honestly, I’d like to see all this frothing reactionary hatred of a system that, on the whole, works pretty well, even if it is as occasionally prone to the whims of schedule and record as any other ranking system where you don’t have repeated roundrobin play, directed at something more worth of hatred, like the NFL’s fucking retarded overtime rules.
For years I’ve been desperately longing for the first Super Bowl to be decided by a coin toss. That day there will be blood in the streets.
(This year’s post-season rule changes are a step in the right direction, but only that)