Yeah there’s always going to be the styrofoam sets, the big flashing lights, the aliens that are really just actors in body paint. I consider the dated effects part of the charm, but I can see being put off by them.
The Horta episode scared me as a kid, but then a lot of stuff on Star Trek scared me. I don’t think the xenomorphs from Alien would have seemed out of place to me. In fact, I couldn’t watch the end credits because it always showed this image, which gave me nightmares:
The writing was spectacular. I mean it was a guy with a rug thrown over him. But you really cared about that mother and her children. And the whole plight with the miners
That’s because they’ve visited you in the night so many times now that your subconscious has become desensitized to them.
When I was a little kid (like around 3 or 4) my mom would let me watch reruns of Star Trek with her. The only creature on the show that she said ever freaked me out was the Gorn, and it scared me so bad she said I spent days wandering around ranting about “Teeth Monster!” and making the hissing noises the Gorn made on the show.
It’s kind of a shame you barely ever hear mention of the Gorn again. Like, you never see them wandering around DS9, they only showed up once on TOS, once on TAS, and were mentioned elsewhere and that was it.
They’re the bad guys in the Star Trek video game that came out around the time of Into Darkness. But I think I may have been the only person who actually played that. Plus - it’s not very good. I mean, J. J. Abrams basically went on the record as saying the game was crap.