The Resistance: Avalon - 2019 Match 2 Game Thread


#480

I agree it sounds far more Evil than Good, but it seems to me like Rowe is getting tired of the game and wants to move on. It sounds a lot like giving up to me.

I’m going to go out of game for a second: Rowe, if you aren’t having fun anymore, I’m sorry. Regardless of what role anyone is I want them to have fun playing.


#481

If there was actual evidence, I would. The problem is that there really isn’t. There’s just a string of events and then speculation about what they might mean. All is clouded by desire, as a fire by smoke, as a mirror by dust.


#482

I really just want to find out what happened on the 2nd mission. Either Dave didn’t fail for some reason or Scott was playing cute with the Spotlight. I don’t get it. Or maybe there was one evil, Dave, and he just forgot to vote fail. I don’t know.

I tried to lay out exactly why I should be trusted as best I could though.


#483

Sorry if I’m coming across negatively. I’ll withdraw my automatic yes as it does come across as giving up. Just don’t know how to argue my case any better.


#484

@Lantz, what’s the time frame for voting? Is it 24 hours? More?


#485

It’s generally as long as it takes. @Lantz will poke the laggards, no need to worry.


#486

Team 5B Vote Results
@scottagibson (leader)
@CF_Kane
@Snebmi
@soondifferent
@rho21

@rho21 - No
@scottagibson - Yes
@soondifferent - Yes
@CF_Kane - No
@CaseyRobinson - No
@Dave_Perkins - No
@Snebmi - Yes
@rowe33 - No

@scottagibson would you like to play Strong Leader at this time?


#487

All votes were in plenty early, I was the delay this time. I blame society.


#488

Vote changes from 5a to 5b were @rho21 and @CF_Kane.

@Lantz, I will not use SL at this time.

@soondifferent, time for your guess.


#489

I strongly prefer team 5A. I do not believe that Snebmi is good.


#490

Snebmi is definitely good. I saw his card!


#491

@soondifferent just a reminder to propose 5C


#492

I think soon is on Sunday vacation.


#493

I’m back!

I guess I was coming around to team 5A before it failed, so I’m not terribly upset that 5B failed as well. So let’s go 5A/C!

@rho21
@rowe33
@scottagibson
@soondifferent
@CF_Kane

@Lantz


#494

Jeez, people keep coming back to Mission 4!

I don’t know what to say other than you’re wrong and this team will fail.

Obviously I’m voting no but I don’t see a clear team for us

Edit: I pressed post before finishing. I meant a don’t see a way for Good to all agree on a team, given the voting.


#495

Dave appealing to reason has convinced me that I need to abandon it.


#496

Team 5C Vote Results
@soondifferent (leader)
@rho21
@rowe33
@scottagibson
@CF_Kane

@rho21 - Yes
@scottagibson - Yes
@soondifferent - Yes
@CF_Kane - Yes
@CaseyRobinson - No
@Dave_Perkins - Yes
@Snebmi - No
@rowe33 - Yes

@rho21 or @scottagibson would you like to play No Confidence?


#497

Dave voted for it? Why?

If we don’t NC it, we lose. Straight-up. The last thing I’m going to say that can help my case even remotely is:

Why the hell wouldn’t Dave fail Mission2 while I was spotlighted?


#498

@Lantz I will not use NC

@rho21 what say you?


#499

Great, making it all my fault. Thanks, scott. ;)

I’m paying no attention to Dave’s vote. A known evil’s only goal here is to sow confusion. I’m not interested in getting into a guessing game on whether it’s a bluff or a double bluff.

It is worth noting though that Dave’s wasn’t the deciding vote: all the players I’m sure are good voted in favour this time.

Ugh, I hate making this sort of decision.