The Resistance: Avalon with Plots - Game 11 - Evil vs Good battle to the death

Kl3mnop · 2015-02-26T14:41:31.000Z

You are insistent that the only explanation for him making the conscious decision not to give OC (or any other card) to annie and jostly is that he didn’t want to be vetted.

I disagree.

scottagibson · 2015-02-26T14:47:21.000Z

Kl3mnop:

You are insistent that the only explanation for him making the conscious decision not to give OC (or any other card) to annie and jostly is that he didn’t want to be vetted.

I disagree.

What causes you to disagree? Put another way, what is the alternative you see that I’m missing? Suggest one that stands up to scrutiny. That’s all you need to do. I’ve laid out my argument; let’s hear yours. Otherwise this exchange is pointless.

rowe33 · 2015-02-26T14:49:17.000Z

Kl3m, what’s your thinking on him handing the cards out all at once? How is that in any way not suspicious? That was the main thing that made me suspect him at the start since I had just done the card handout last game.

Kl3mnop · 2015-02-26T14:51:01.000Z

scottagibson:

What causes you to disagree? Put another way, what is the alternative you see that I’m missing? Suggest one that stands up to scrutiny. That’s all you need to do. I’ve laid out my argument; let’s hear yours. Otherwise this exchange is pointless.

Yeah, ummmm, OK.

Regardless, this exchange has been anything but pointless.

Kl3mnop · 2015-02-26T14:52:23.000Z

rowe33:

Kl3m, what’s your thinking on him handing the cards out all at once? How is that in any way not suspicious? That was the main thing that made me suspect him at the start since I had just done the card handout last game.

Dude, annie just tried to put FOUR people on Team 1. It’s not like the mechanics are obvious.

scottagibson · 2015-02-26T14:53:13.000Z

Kl3mnop:

Yeah, ummmm, OK.

Regardless, this exchange has been anything but pointless.

Crickets.

Kl3mnop · 2015-02-26T14:57:05.000Z

scottagibson:

Crickets.

You silly!

rowe33 · 2015-02-26T15:09:22.000Z

Kl3mnop:

Dude, annie just tried to put FOUR people on Team 1. It’s not like the mechanics are obvious.

I think these are two pretty different type of ‘mistakes’…I’m willing to admit that I could possibly be wrong but I find it hard to believe. fire’s clear explanation in her post + rob not being new + if rob is Good there’s no way in hell he hands out the other two cards w/o getting the results of the first one = Evil to me.

Dave_Perkins · 2015-02-26T15:44:34.000Z

I had a busy day but soon not so busy!

Dave_Perkins · 2015-02-26T15:45:09.000Z

I literally can’t even imagine what there is already to talk about at such length.

I love it!

robthomasson · 2015-02-26T15:52:37.000Z

rowe33:

I think these are two pretty different type of ‘mistakes’…I’m willing to admit that I could possibly be wrong but I find it hard to believe. fire’s clear explanation in her post + rob not being new + if rob is Good there’s no way in hell he hands out the other two cards w/o getting the results of the first one = Evil to me.

I can assure you that - evil or not - me handing out all cards at once was just a stupid error. Either way I would have benefitted from doing them one at a time. Never mistake incompetence for conspiracy.

The real black mark against me in this court is not choosing Annie or jostly because I wanted to learn more (I already know I’m good) and I had reacted to comments to not put those after me on the team. Scott called it a weak reason - and clearly he is correct on the evidence of the attention it is still getting.

fire · 2015-02-26T20:40:34.000Z

Dear Knights! I am about two hours into a seven-hour cross-state traverse and thus vote results may be delayed.

fire · 2015-02-27T01:01:27.000Z

The quest team shall go!

6 YES
4 NO

Player     	V
==========================
robthomasson	Yes
ankamela	No
scottagibson	Yes
Blips     	No
Dave Perkins	Yes
rowe33     	Yes
Christien Murawski	Yes
Kl3mnop     	No
clyve      	No
jostly     	Yes

fire · 2015-02-27T01:02:34.000Z

rowe33 holds No Confidence.

Would you like to nullify this approved team?

rowe33 · 2015-02-27T01:32:41.000Z

No I’ll hold onto it…I have no idea why Annie is voting No to her own party though. You don’t want scott to get cards but you picked him for your quest? You don’t trust me despite my double star rating? +1 suspicion point!

clyve · 2015-02-27T05:18:16.000Z

Rob voted yes to this team…?

ankamela · 2015-02-27T05:23:38.000Z

I didn’t! I voted YES. Fire’s travel notes got mixed up- PAUSE THE GAME

scottagibson · 2015-02-27T05:34:43.000Z

ankamela:

I didn’t! I voted YES. Fire’s travel notes got mixed up- PAUSE THE GAME

Whew!

rowe33 · 2015-02-27T06:45:32.000Z

ankamela:

I didn’t! I voted YES. Fire’s travel notes got mixed up- PAUSE THE GAME

I was worried fire had Evil on her quest…guess this confirms it.

robthomasson · 2015-02-27T07:41:50.000Z

clyve:

Rob voted yes to this team…?

Mais oui.