The Resistance: Avalon with Plots - Game 11 - Evil vs Good battle to the death

Kl3mnop · 2015-03-01T20:11:27.000Z

All I want is a simple answer, not a revised list. Otherwise, noise continues…

ChristienMurawski · 2015-03-01T20:12:21.000Z

I’m sorry. I’m with Dave on this (totally, if not orally). Where in the world does Dave being evil come from? I get everyone thinking I’m evil, because of my magical rob-card-dispensation-connection (this thankfully has not hurt us), but Dave? What is that?

I need help with that.

Now clyve. He’s crazy evil. Obviously.

-xtien

Blips · 2015-03-01T20:14:35.000Z

@Kl3mnop, wait, are you saying that (EVIL) Dave is, actually, Evil?

Jokes aside, there is no actual evidence against Dave, just a lot of guessing.

Here are my personal opinions on allegiance ordered from good to evil in descending order:

blips - 100% good (I know I’m good)
scottagibson - 75% good
rowe33 - 70% good
annie - 65% good
jostly - 60% good
clyve - 55% good
dave - 35% good
christien - 35% good
Kl3mnop - 20% good
rob - 10% good (boy is he evil!)

Kl3mnop · 2015-03-01T20:19:01.000Z

Blips:

@Kl3mnop, wait, are you saying that (EVIL) Dave is, actually, Evil?

Jokes aside, there is no actual evidence against Dave, just a lot of guessing.

I didn’t say a damn thing about Dave. rowe33 did. I just thought his list was curious as hell given the inclusion of clyve in GOOD and marking of Dave and x-tien as EVIL.

But he doesn’t seem to want to address that? I mean, he published The List. You’d think that meant he intended some discussion.

Blips · 2015-03-01T20:22:45.000Z

Kl3mnop:

I didn’t say a damn thing about Dave.

I was just laughing at your post:

Kl3mnop:

If Rejected leadership will nominally pass to (EVIL) Dave.
If Approved you will then have a chance to play No Confidence, which would still Reject the team…with leadership nominally passing to (EVIL) Dave.
In either case that leadership passes to (EVIL) Dave, scottagibson will be given the opportunity to use Strong Leader and take leadership away from (EVIL) Dave.

Kl3mnop · 2015-03-01T20:32:49.000Z

Blips:

I was just laughing at your post:

Glad you picked up on the message.

Clearly you feel similar to rowe33 by your listed %EVIL.

Poor Dave. That’s what he gets for being all kooky.

jostly · 2015-03-01T21:32:44.000Z

scottagibson:

I’m inclined to give Blips the benefit of the doubt here. But, I’d bow to the wishes of my fellow knights from quest 2 - annie, rowe, and jostly. Can you three please weigh in with a clear vote as to what we should do?

Note that if we decide to take over, I think we must wait until after the team vote. If the team passes, annie will have to No Confidence then I can SL. If the team fails, I think I can SL at that point.

Wow, a lot of things were said while I was asleep. :) Here’s my thought:

If it turns out the first team proposal is the one we vote on, we vote it down. Should be possible to do without using a No Confidence card. But after that, don’t waste a strong leader. Let Dave propose a team, and see if he picks us as a team. If he does, we’re good to go, and should evil somehow be on the team (after 2 successful votes?), we’ve got rowe to distribute the cards.

If we had used Strong Leader in that scenario, we’d be back at Blips distributing cards and proposing the next team, and that seems like a silly place to put us in with one or two wasted cards.

jostly · 2015-03-01T21:36:25.000Z

In addendum to the above post, I’d add that this scheme gives Dave a chance to prove he’s good. I don’t know where the suspect-Dave is coming from, but I’ve seen nothing suspicious from him this game except voting yes to the first team with suspected evil, and Dave always does that.

fire · 2015-03-01T21:42:09.000Z

omfg guys

I’m catching up now. In the meantime, I send you this:

Christien Murawski holds Keeping a close eye on you
rowe33 holds No Confidence
ankamela holds No Confidence
Blips holds Opinion Maker
ankamela holds Opinion Maker
scottagibson holds Strong Leader
rowe33 holds Keeping a close eye on you

Blips · 2015-03-01T21:43:31.000Z

fire:

omfg guys

haha sorry :)

fire · 2015-03-01T21:43:38.000Z

Knightsaber:

(Peanut Gallery)

You’d have to play Strong Leader before cards were passed out.

(/Peanut Gallery)

This is true. Strong Leader can only be played after a failed quest team vote (rejected, or No Confidenced), or after the end of a quest when a new leader has been assigned but cards have not gone out.

Scott didn’t have the Strong Leader card yet at the last time he could have used it.

fire · 2015-03-01T21:51:50.000Z

My ruling is as follows.

Blips:

My team selection is: scottagibson, rowe33, annie, and myself

Blips:

Oh, and since I have an Opinion Maker, I’ll be voting yes.

Because a team was called – not up for discussion, as in “hey guys, what do you think of this” – and a vote was submitted publicly, we’ll have to go with this team selection.

jostly · 2015-03-01T21:59:25.000Z

I don’t see any reason not to play it safe here, and get the last team back together. Hence, I’m going to vote no to this.

fire · 2015-03-01T22:11:04.000Z

Opinion Maker Blips voted yes. We need ankamela to vote first and publicly as well.

ankamela · 2015-03-02T06:33:05.000Z

ankamela votes no

Dave_Perkins · 2015-03-02T07:15:01.000Z

This is a tough call for me (yes/no on this team) because I’d love to have cards to distribute after this team goes. The team does have annie/scott/rowe, who were on both of our successful teams, so only Blips is new (replacing jostly). Hmmmm…

Well, having only one piece of evidence against Blips (namely, that he voted No on the first successful team of annie/scott/rowe), I’ll vote…

(sending PM)

^^ Just a paper trail so that everyone who is like omg Dave plays wacky and who knows what clownass move he’ll pull next can have a shred to grasp

scottagibson · 2015-03-02T07:27:35.000Z

Per my exchange with Blips, I’ll be voting ‘yes’ to this team. His card distribution and his willingness to change his team selection when I asked could be a calculated bluff, but I doubt it. Let’s see what the team vote looks like, and then decide whether to proceed with this team or not.

Dave_Perkins · 2015-03-02T07:31:56.000Z

What does your last sentence mean, scott?

fire · 2015-03-02T07:33:41.000Z

ankamela:

ankamela votes no

Now accepting all votes.

Kl3mnop · 2015-03-02T07:35:28.000Z

scottagibson:

His card distribution and his willingness to change his team selection when I asked…

I love this! “So long as people do exactly as I say, they’re OK with me!”

Too bad rob was asleep overseas after his initial card distro. You guys could have browbeat him to your desired result as well, then he’d be clearly GOOD!