Just caught up here. Thanks for including me in the team.
I was pleasantly surprised to see the first quest team succeed. It is still possible, or even likely, that it contained evil. If it did and the current team goes forward and then fails - I will come under suspicion. In such a circumstance clyve can use his Keeping A Close Eye On You card on me - I would probably be the best choice for that examination (unless clyve himself is evil).
As I am good I cannot vote against this team. So my PM will be on its way to fire once this post is done.
Nikolaj
102
So you’re saying that it’s likely that the first team had an evil knight in it, but you can’t vote against the same team (plus yourself) because you’re good? I don’t understand.
I am voting for it because I don’t know of a better team. Even if I was absolutely sure there was evil on it, it could still be a better team to have in play than one for which we have no information. We know Scott knows Rowe’s alignment, we know they all voted success on the first quest. If this team goes forward and then fails we will have a set number of possible scenarios and we have clyve waiting to examine somebody’s quest vote to reduce that number.
What we need most of all is information and I think that using this team is a better way to more information than starting from scratch with another team.
Blips
104
if this next quest fails, I’d say there is a 33% chance both Scott and Rowe are EVIL.
I’m voting yes on the team and my reasons are X Y Z in that order.
fire
106
Quest 2 is approved!
8 YES
2 NO
The team:
Christien Murawski (team leader), rowe33, robthomasson, scottagibson
The votes:
Player V
=====================
rowe33 Yes
Christien Murawski Yes
robthomasson Yes
Nikolaj No
scottagibson Yes
ankamela Yes
Blips Yes
Dave Perkins Yes
zeroshift11 No
clyve Yes
fire
107
robthomasson holds No Confidence
Dave Perkins holds No Confidence
Do either of you wish to nullify this approved team?
Sic passim - I will not use my No Confidence card on this team.
fire
109
Neither player wishes to use No Confidence to nullify this approved team. This team will be going on Quest 2!
Scott, do you wish to use In the Spotlight to force one quest team member to submit their vote publicly?
I feel like using it now would be a waste. I know rowe is a true knight, but the rest of you have only my word for that. I could play it on him to demonstrate, but that would hardly be conclusive, since it’s only one vote. And I know he’s a vote for success anyway!
As for Christien - he’s part of a winning team, and my gut tells me he’s good. With Rob we have less to go on, but there’s no reason to suspect him now.
So I’ll save it until we need it, thanks. Hopefully we never will - if this quest succeeds, we’re nearly there!
I agree. Save it for someone that you suspect is evil.
fire
112
Ok! Quest team, please PM me your super secret quest vote.
Good must vote Success and Evil may choose Success or Failure.
clyve
113
I think passing on the Spotlight may have been a mistake. It would have helped triangulate evil if there is any… Now there will be wiggle room.
clyve
114
I’ve got a chart update soon but its on my iPad. I’ll send it when I get a chance this morning
rowe33
115
We still have the Eye card at least, just in case it’s needed. Plus whatever cards rob picks up for the next quest. We’ll learn something one way or the other.
Zeroshift1, I’m curious why you voted against this team? Nicolaj did as well, but he offered an explanation.
I have my suspicions of particular people in said party.
clyve
118
On that vague and suspicious note:
rowe33
119
Not really sure what to make of the chart so far - 7 people have voted yes for both parties (including the 3 of us that are in both) while the other 3 are split. No one’s voted no to both.
I do find it suspicious that rob’s name is capitalized in the chart above!
clyve
120
Shoot! I had noticed that and meant to change it :P
