Let’s cool the rhetoric off a notch on all sides. For those of us who are not parties to the dispute, this is not worth getting angry over.
As an analogy, it actually works ok. Intellectual property rights are not one thing, but are a bundle of many different rights. It’s reasonably accurate (though imprecise) to characterize F+P as having “sold” the trademark right to Accolade, while having held onto the copyrights (except for SC3), and to say that Stardock bought those trademark-and-SC3 rights later (if they were still actually owned by Accolade->Atari, and had not yet reverted to F+P, which I believe is a contested point), and to say that F+P still own the copyrights on SC1 and SC2.
I’m just continually amused at the twitter-stardock rhetoric that they’re shocked, shocked that the people they sued might fight back.
If there’s a reason, @Jason_McMaster, that it seems like people are being unfair to Stardock, it’s because their public statements are full of what I can only call…whoppers. Meaning statements that are so egregiously incorrect that it’s hard to even imagine that they believe them. The biggest of these, of course, is the newly-found synthetic religion of Fred And Paul Didn’t Create Star Control, which nobody actually believes, but which they keep trotting out over and over. So when one points out that a whopper like that is what it is, it’s pretty hard to do so without adopting the tone of “Look, how stupid do you think people really are?”
So every week new people find out about the dispute, and every week they will find some fragment of a conversation that, say, contains complete whoppers about copyright law that are so incorrect they could give you lead poisoning, and I think it’s no wonder that it can look like people are “ganging up” on Stardock.
My favorite whopper of the moment is from Brad’s twitter feed this week where Brad, who has sent approximately 6.3 million(*) tweets about the lawsuit, expressed shock and horror that F+P would be so unwise as to send one (1) tweet about the case, and he’s sure they didn’t run it by their counsel first.
It’s just unspeakable behavior.
(*) Number is exaggerated for comedic effect. Actually it was only 4.7 million.