The US Military Catch-All Thread


#363

She’s referencing this article in Forbes. The number is that high because the DoD (edit - and HUD, combined) has been using unsupported plugs. This is extremely reckless accounting. At year end, a regular company will likely make numerous adjustments to the balance sheet for various reasons but there should be a reason or proper support behind each transaction.


#364

She was actually referencing the Nation article. You can see an image of it here:

But I guess the Nation piece referenced the article in Forbes?

But it’s not actually indicating that the DoD spent $21T in money… it’s basically that there are accounting errors. And likely, the same error is showing up multiple times in that overall running total.

Because the idea that the DoD spent $21T “without telling us” is nonsensical on its face. It’d mean it was spending more than a Trillion dollars every year. Hell, in 1998, the entire federal budget was only $1.6 in its entirety. The DoD would have had to spend 5 times what it was allotted. There’s just no way that happened.

Accounting errors don’t equate to actual money being spent. Like, fixing those errors isn’t gonna actually yield money to spend on other stuff.


#365

Not sure where this goes, but it’s beathtaking.

So much for the McChrystal is a military genius takes we were getting during the Obama administration.


#366

It turns out not having an end game has it’s issues.


#367

Yes, “muddle along” is perhaps the apex of 21st century military strategic thought.


#368

Before criticizing the general, I’d be interested in knowing what they told him his mission was, and what it’s victory conditions were.

Because i suspect in the case of Afghanistan, both were nebulous, and likely had unrealistic restrictions placed upon them in terms of what kinds of forces he could employ.


#369

In which case it’s his job to say that’s a totally fucked up plan, sir, and I can’t in good conscience take kids over there to die for that shit.


#370

Well, he’s not commander over there anymore.


#371

I imagine the mission back then was no less nebulous and stupid, so he should have said it then. Now he should say unless we intend to own that place, we should get those troops out. Asking them to die for muddling is, well, something.


#372

I agree.


#373

#374

Well, to be fair, at least Geraldo Rivera.