PS1: Walt Disney World Quest: Magical Racing Tour
-great racing game, which was later re-made into higher resolution for the dreamcast
-it plays like Mario Kart, and the levels are awesome
-you can play it with your small kids without traumatizing them
If you are going to play Dark Cloud 2, just skip Dark Cloud 1.
IIRC, Parappa and Umjammer Lammy are really hard to find. Gitaroo Man was as well, but they did a re-release at some point in the PS2 life cycle, and so it came down to a reasonable price (ditto for Rez, which has since gotten HD re-releases).
Valkyrie Profile - Just an amazing JRPG. For a PS1 game the graphics still hold up nicely. Absolutely loved the soundtrack and setting.
Rival Schools - I’m typically not a big fan of fighting games, but aside from the Tekken games, I had a blast with Rival Schools. Probably helped a bit that I was in high school at the time.
Vigilante 8 - Sorry Twisted Metal, Vigilante 8 was better. I remember you could do custom soundtracks too by swapping out the game for a music cd.
Bust A Groove - After Parappa the Rapper I was craving more rhythm based games and this one satisfied my need. Haven’t played this one in years so I have no idea how it’s held up, but I did hit up ebay thinking about getting a cheap copy, but it’s pretty pricey online.
This game answered the question of why giant robots were always laying waste to huge parts of Tokyo while ostensibly protecting it from giant space monsters. The robots were controlled by teenagers!
Gradius V Katamari Damacy Shin Megami Tensei Nocturne Breath of Fire Dragon Quarter Shadow of the Colossus Ico Okami is pretty cool, but bring a pillow God Hand Valkyrie Profile 2, but skip the cutscenes if you value your mental health
There are a bunch of multiplatform gems like:
Burnout series
Viewtiful Joe
Resident Evil 4
Stay away from:
Silent Hill 2. People are going to tell you this is great. These people are insane. It’s complete shit - not scary, dreadful gameplay and wildly inconsistent graphics.
Final Fantasy X. Absolutely awful in just about every respect.
The Kingdom Hearts games are real bad.
Metal Gear is real bad.
PS1:
Silent Hill
Gradius Gaiden (Japan only)
Yoyo’s Puzzle Park
Castlevania Symphony of the Night
Although it seems pointless to play it now, I think GTA3 was an awesome experience when I first played it. Just being able to jump in a car and drive around like a maniac was so much fun.
Incredible Crisis
Parasite Eve 2
Dino Crisis
Wipeout XL
Megaman Legends 1 and 2
Fear Effect 1 and 2
Syphon Filter 1 and 2
My wife loved Baby Universe(Japan only.)
PS2:
SSX Tricky was the absolute best of the series.
Project Eden was a flawed game that I loved
Okage: The Shadow King
Onimusha
Tony Hawk…3 I think that was the one
Metal Gear Solid 3
Devil May Cry
Soul Reaver 2
Twisted Metal Black
…and I’m sure I’m forgetting some. I keep having to stop myself from listing n64 games as well. :)
Playstation 1: Legend of Mana. I know people say the Secret was better (SNES), but I never played it. Legend holds up to this day, though, and it’s available on the PS3 store.
PS2- the already mentioned Robot Alchemic Drive (RAD). Game is frikken awesome.
For my money Silent Hill 3 is every bit as great as SH2 or the Fatal Frame series when it comes to horror games.
On a very different note, I want to give props to Way Of The Samurai 1 & 2. They’re ARPGs that are more Soul Calibur than Diablo due to a pretty good timing-based combat system. And unlike most ARPGs, each playthrough is brief. But that’s because the games are designed around the hope that you’ll replay them time and time again. And it’s not just the loot grind - there are many different branches in the story that also encourage this.
Not that the stories are very good, but they certainly top what was done in the likes of Diablo 3 or Torchlight.
They do feel a bit shallow in some ways. The randomly generated missions (which contribute to a sort of warring-factions mechanic) seem pretty cool until you realize that there’s really only five or six types of mission that a certain faction will ever give you, leading to a lot of repetition. If you remember the guild quests in Daggerfall - yeah, it’s a lot like that. And the gameworlds are really small, so if you’re more of the “let me explore a huge world” kind of RPG player then there isn’t much for you here.
Still, I consider WotS one of the best flawed-but-classic series out there.