Ok, so “All Our Yesterdays” is our episode for discussion this week. I really loved this episode. The Enterprise arrives at a planet whose star is about to go nova. They find that the planet has possibly been evacuated, perhaps? There’s one last person left, a librarian and his copies who are minding a library that keeps an archive of their knowledge, and a time machine (Atavachron) that lets him send people into the past after he’s “prepared them”.
McCoy starts browsing Ice Age 26 and starts laughing over the little creatures antics. Kirk starts watching old episodes of Wagon Train, and Spock tries to peer over the shoulder of the librarian to try to figure out what an Atavachron is. Meanwhile, Kirk hears a random woman’s cry for help and immediately steps through the Atavachron and into a 3 Musketeers set. Spock and McCoy try to follow him and end up in an ice age period. Enjoyable antics follow.
I have to admit, this really tickled me, this whole concept. Your star is going nova, and you don’t have the ability to locate to a different planet, but you do have time travel technology, so you send everyone in your civilization to a point in your past. The convicts get to go too, but they get sent to an ice age. I wonder what rules of time travel are being observed here. Wouldn’t this level of interference change the future? The people sent back seem to mostly be blending in and not trying to change anything. Maybe there’s a set of rules they follow? Not to say that there’s much they can change from what we see there.
Still, I like this as a mental exercise. If what our genes want is to be passed forward to successive generations, by going into the past, that’s still being accomplished. You’re still passing on your genes and having children. They’re just more and more likely to be absorbed into the knowledge and culture of whatever past era they’ve gone to. Possibly procreating with your ancestors actually.
But wait, that’s not all! This episode is secretly about a couple of other things too. Mr Spock finally finds love? If you just told me that premise, I’d think it would be so boring. Just two Vulcans being really formal with one another. But no, Spock wasn’t prepared properly, he went into the past and reverted to base-instincts Spock who feels passionately about this woman he loves. I think this really worked for me in large part due to the casting and Nemoy’s excellent work here. As mentioned upthread, Ms Mariette Hartley is not just hot, she has a “girl next door” look, so you can also see Spock actually giving up Starfleet and actually settle down with her here in this Ice Age era. Since this is the second last episode, as a viewer of this episode in March 1969, I could conceivable believe that this is the last goodbye for Mr. Spock, and it is one that I would have been happy with actually. If you’re going to devolve to your baser instincts, finding passion and love is not a bad way to live out the rest of your years.
There’s other things in this episode, but I’ll wait for further posts to follow up on those things. But these two were the main themes that I loved in this episode. If this had been the last episode of the series, never to be seen again, it would have made a pretty good finale actually. An episode about living your future by escaping into the past.