No contest, play BG2EE. Even if you stack it against any modern rpg it will likely come out on top. Such an incredible game, I recently went through it (multiple times) and I was floored at how focused the design structures of the world and quests were. Absolutely incredible, I don’t know if I’ve ever played a game with such scope that was so focused, and with so little filler.
Out of curiosity, have you played BG2 before?
@gurugeorge: high five. I thought I was the only one on this forum who hasn’t played PS:T, lol. It’s one of my gaming sins that I still haven’t fixed. One day, maybe. I did enjoy the new Torment though, but never finished it before I got sidetracked with other games.