Lantz
5449
I think that there’s a common mistake to assume that people who believe crazy things are mentally ill. In this case a lot of self centered assholes believe the lies because the lies tell them that they are special. That they are the ‘real’ Americans. That their culture is the best one. They don’t believe these lies because they have a mental illness, they believe these lies because they care only about themselves and are happy to live in a world of lies as long as it’s their lies.
aeneas
5450
A 100% reasonable take for these cowards.
JoshL
5451
Hunh, weird. I swear I heard a couple dozen Congresspeople saying that Trump’s words weren’t responsible for the invasion of the Capitol?
Or to put it another way, Trump has been underbussed by a face-painted horn-wearing organic-food eating terrorist.
Little known fact: Q Shaman is antifa.
Nesrie
5453
That’s where the swears came in. It’s like the most predictable pattern we have. Someone, white group or person, commits a clear crime, like something so obvious that even the other pattern of wait, there must be more to the story, couldn’t possibly work so we go to step No.2 oh, but oh they must be mentally ill… like clockwork.
Well, the jury is still out among some at least.
If you think mentally ill should or should not be coddled, that is your issue. Like I said, many of the rioters/Trumpists still function well, maybe well enough to serve time. Plenty of people (especially minorities) end up incarcerated for much more minor things–including being ill. These rioters may in fact be coddled, but it’s not for being ill but despite it.
Nesrie
5455
There is no reason to believe that these people are mentally ill, and I am sick and tired of watching white people parade a line of predictable excuses out every time crimes are committed by a white person, and it sure as hell is not something the same people ever bother to do for people of different colors.
You’re being a jerk trying to twist my words to justify your ready made excuses.
I get that the mob on Jan 6 got everyone rattled, but I really hope the security forces are not turning all their attention to crowd control in the coming days. It would surprise me a lot if there is another demonstration that goes the same way as the Pence insurrection attempt. I’d be much more worried about lone or small group domestic terrorists carrying out Breivik-like attacks on high-profile Democratic targets or events. Given how deranged (i.e., brainwashed) some of these people are, who knows what some of them might resort to when their world comes crashing down around them?
Tim_N
5457
My dad in Australia literally said this to me yesterday. Rather, “he has heard things” and that he isn’t definitely saying it is so, but rather there’s no proof either way. This type of propaganda is so infuriating to fight.
Clay
5458
Isn’t that like the worst way to pay somebody b/c the blockchain will hold the transaction history? @JoshL is the expert here.
Anyhow…
I kind of wish they had waited to charge them all until after the inauguration.
I’m sorry. My point is that just because people like Trump or whoever are using mental illness as an excuse (and they definitely are, to shift attention away from gun control for instance) doesn’t mean it isn’t actually true. More importantly, these people are also violent. That’s one reason why they’re dangerous. And I’m not talking about all of them, but higher than the national average. A lot.
I said this. Plenty of non-Whites suffer from mental illness, and most/many are non-violent yet end up incarcerated anyway. Or end up incarcerated (or murdered) for some other minor bullshit. This is a fact.
Nesrie
5461
Oh sure. You said that here in this topic, the one that covers hundreds maybe thousands of… white people. Based on pretty much nothing other than Trump’s personality seems crazy, people are saying crazy things and there are handful of backseat articles making broad statements about groups of people instead of individuals.
You probably think that graphic up there is a frustrating, unfair, and not specific to this case… well try being on the other side. Try being at the bottom of it. Try knowing, without a doubt, that had this been a group of black individuals storming a federal government almost no one would be talking about their mental state or their food in jail because they’d be freaking dead.
You want a fact. That’s a freaking fact. These people are lucky to be alive, and most of them are alive because they are white. And because they are white there will be no shortage of excuses piling up for them, some just made up fantasies, because the only thing worse than watching a bunch of white people fail to overthrow the US government for White America is actually taking responsibility for it.
I get that emotions are running high and the topic is irksome because the rioters, etc. are hiding behind people’s sympathies. (And I’m NOT sympathetic. I think I made that clear.) But I don’t see how denying that mental health might be a factor helps devise an effective strategy against them. There’s been loads of shitty strategy over the past 4+ years, like believing Trump couldn’t win, believing that Bush 2000 couldn’t win (I did this too and didn’t vote!), believing that Bush 2004 couldn’t win, half-assing the “deplorables” remark, “we don’t really need masks”, etc. etc.
Houngan
5464
I’m thinking it’s because mental health is an issue that needs a lot of enhanced attention, but it doesn’t apply to percentages of crowds. In that 2-5 thousand or whatever, there were certainly 10-20 people with mental health issues that might have been a contributing factor to them being there and attacking the seat of US government. The rest have a cultural issue, an intelligence issue, and a privilege issue.
Where does brainwashing land on the mental health spectrum?
Near Stockholm syndrome, somewhere.