Weird Win10 wireless XB1 controller problem

It detects/pairs after powering on but the Xbox button light disappears and the controller disappears from Windows immediately after.

If I pair a newer XB1 controller wirelessly with bluetooth instead it persists instead of disappearing.

Anyone else having this type of problem? Tried three different (Elite, v1.0 one and modified one with BT) controllers and it’s not batteries or the controller but seemingly the Win10 driver. Wired micro USB works for all 3 of course.