The Rogue One is objectively wrong to include in this list, as Rogue One was a very good Star Wars movie, and therefore it is not an overreaction but merely a stating of preference.
Yeah that should be replaced with “The prequels we’re better than the last Jedi” which I’ve seen several times. Each time it feels like the unmasking in they eye of the beholder twilight zone episode.
Wait a minute, asking whether adding Portal characters and mechanics into a completely separate kind of game makes that a Portal game is a huge overreaction? Man the Internet is weird.