I didn’t like it on the merits. It was also colossally stupid to do it, both because of the general public backlash and because it embarassed the hell out of the NFL.
I disliked it because it was a blatant and stupid attempt to drum up support for two celebrities who’s stars are fading. The “unplanned malfunction” claims afterwards made things worse.
Didn’t like it at all. Of course, it could have something to do with the fact that we had kids watching the game with us. That kind of cheap BS has no place on public TV during a family sporting event. I want to know how many people here have children and thought it was ok?
I have a four year old daughter. I couldn’t care less about her happening to see exposed breasts (not that she generally does). She’s still living in blissful ignorance that the general public finds nudity shameful, and as long as we can keep it that way we will.
If I remember right, the song Jackson was singing had a lot of bump and grinding and extremely non-subtle sexual innuendo. I find it… humorous that parents were ok with kids watching the TV up to the breast slip but then shocked and appalled at the breast.
“Mommy, what is Janet doing? Why is she acting like that?”
“Shh, we’re watching the TV honey”
“Oh my GOD what’s that???”
Its not a matter of nudity, as the “experts” say… its that seeing nudity takes little intelligence, no critical thought. Interpreting a dance and having to judge it and having to judge your child’s reaction to it… that takes work. That takes a level of consideration of your child that most parents are not willing to undergo. So they act AS IF the nudity is the point. Good for a laugh…
The other aspect of this issue is that a lot of people (mainly liberals) think that entertainment has no ability to influence. They think they are sophisticated and non-repressed for letting their children watch anything. A subset of the liberal Manifest Destiny worldview. However, even many of these people draw the line at nudity (a trait they share for different reasons with conservatives) so the liberal chorus of “Oh my what’s that???” joins voices with the conservatives…
Solution: Taking a greater interest in the life of your child, applying critical thought toward your child’s environment, and encouraging a good environment for your child’s effective development.
Parent: “If only they didn’t show the breast! Damn MTV for ruining my child!”
Yes, I know, dances by American entertainers are supposed to be merely “entertaining” (that is to say, Hedonistic and Dionysian), and this thought is so ingrained that the mere idea of actually interpreting a dance by Janet Jackson is met with great puzzlement.
“But, I thought dances were meaningless outside of entertainment value?”
Part of the silver lining to the dark cloud of the recently successful conservative movement in America is that Hollywood will finally start to be seen rationally (by some people, anyway). That Hollywood as a culture will gain more critical looks than what they’ve dealt with in the past.
So two things: There is the meaning OF entertainment value and there is meaning of entertaining things on top of them being entertaining.