Wonder Woman 2017 - Beating Marvel to the punch


I also was half-expecting this kind of approach, and that would have been a welcome criticism on the weaknesses of humanity; Ares shows up, sees the devastation and bloodshed, and with a shrug of his shoulders mutters something like “I guess my work was already done. Well done, mortals.”


I’m pretty sure they decided that Ares was necessary largely to wrap up the “divine origin” part of Diana’s story, not necessarily as a “big bad guy prodding humans to do bad things” character. With him out of the picture, there aren’t any gods left to meddle in Diana’s affairs and future movies don’t have to worry about using them in the story. Unless they want to, of course.


I thought it would have been cool that in one of the scenes of the German troops after Ares’ defeat, you saw a young Corporal Adolf Hitler slink out of the trenches . . .


Nah. I’m pretty sure he was there because Wonder Woman’s revamped Brian Azzarello origin matched up nicely with the movie studio’s need to have a special effects heavy blockbuster last act. The fact that they had to twist the story (painfully) to account for Ares being the last living god made this obvious because they were clearing the slate and making sure they wouldn’t have to deal with a pantheon of Greek gods in the modern day JLA movies.


I think you’re over-analyzing it. I believe the studio just wanted the movie to have a boss fight, because super hero movies need boss fights.

They sorta had to give WW an god-like enemy, that German dude taking Super Soldier Serum wasn’t going to cut it. She already tanked Doomsday in BvS, who swatted Superman away like a fly and Batman spent 10 minutes kiting and trying not to get hit. So they had to match that.


That’s what I was getting at. Could have been done without Ares, true, but I didn’t mind the way they ended up going.


Yeah, I wouldn’t have minded it if Ares had just shown up having heard of Diana’s exploits on the front, or had been trapped by the humans, like that Dr lady (who was also awesome) in some way, further proving him correct about the nature of humans, rather than just being “Oh, it is that guy from before”

Remus Lupin is the god of war, got it.

Movie was still amazing though, these are all minor nitpicks, and they mostly went with “Humans basically did this on their own”


Wonder Woman has now surpassed both all other DCEU movies in domestic box office.

Man of Steel - $291 million
Suicide Squad - $325 million
Batman v Superman - $330 million
Wonder Woman - $330.5 million

That said, it’s made $663 million worldwide, so it has a way to go to beat Batman v Superman’s worldwide box office of $873 million.


So I just saw this and thought it was one of the best superhero flicks made except for the last 15 minutes or so - but up until then, pretty much perfect. Was so glad Zack Snyder didn’t direct but was surprised he produced and co-wrote it.

But I’m confused about one thing: assuming she’s about 25 years old when she meets Chris Pine’s character, does that mean the battle between Zeus and Ares only took place around 1895 or so? Does that even make sense?


I got the impression that the Island kind of stood still in time, like a portal of some kind which is why you can’t return to it, sort. And Diana is immortal so that’s why she doesn’t age later.

I am not a comic book reader, so I am just pulling off what i saw, that the Amazon’s didn’t age and really didn’t advance either from the ancient era.


But it wasn’t really a portal - more like the island was in permanent stealth mode. At least that’s the impression I got.


If it’s only a cloak, why can’t she ever return again? I am pretty sure it’s more than a cloak.


I wasn’t paying close attention, I thought they meant she couldn’t return not in a literal way, but more in the sense that she was throwing her lot in with humanity and would no longer have a place in their society.

Steve and the Germans just accidentally crashed into the island, there certainly wasn’t anything stopping them from landing there, only the fact that they wouldn’t have known to look for an island there. There didn’t seem to be any more significance to it than that—they lucked into it. No mystical protection beyond hiding it, nothing like the island from LOST jumping through time and space or the mystical city of K’un-Lun appearing every seven years or anything fancy like that.


I took it as literal. Voluntarily leaving the island means she cannot return.The island was protected by being hidden, but it seems like once you leave you can’t find it again. Nothing really stopped them from finding it by accident aside from the fact that ancient boats would have a hard time navigating those rocks in the fog and probably be broken apart.


Huh. This was certainly not terrible and I’d watch it again if it pops up on Netflix or something, but I came out of it being somewhat underwhelmed. I guess all the positive reviews had heightened my expectations too much, and some gushing articles made it seem like the combo of female hero lead and Patti Jenkins’s direction was some sort of game changer or at least made for a bit of a different comic movie experience. Sadly, it wasn’t - especially when the third act kicked in.

To its credit, most of the cast was rather likeable - that has not the case for some of the recent Warner/DC movies. I also liked some character arc aspects. When the marksman screws up in the second act and is unable to hit the other sniper, you 100% expect that there’ll be a big scene in the third act where he’ll have to overcome whatever trauma it is to save the day. And then that didn’t happen, and I actually liked that.

I also appreciate that the movie stands on its own and was not as heavily tied into other DCU movies as it could have been. Brief Wayne Enterprise cameo aside, they didn’t emphasise the other DCU notably and even refrained from having a post-credits scene. I also like her music theme–it’s been introduced in BvS already, I know–which is distinct and memorable. I wouldn’t be able to spontaneously hum any other recent superhero theme.

The second act works best, I thought. That part when she plows through the village and her theme music kicks in - wonderful.

As for the parts that didn’t work as well for me… some of the dialog was really cringeworthy, and I was about to laugh/groan when the “LOVE!” bit came up - just as I was when Anne Hathaway’s Interstellar line made its appearance.

I also thought Gal Gadot’s performance was serviceable, but not enthralling. I never really cared about Captain America, but Chris Evans, being the affable fella he is, helped me getting sold on it. Gal Gadot’s WW is more akin to Chris Hemsworth’s Thor (first movie) in that he wasn’t bad and looked up to the part, but without making the character his own the way Evans, Bale, or RDJ did with their respective heroes. (Mind you, Hemsworth has grown on me a bit over the course of several MVU movies and bits in other movies.)

The finale was a letdown because it was mostly about walking down a trodden path. I really David Thewlis and was initially happy to see him in this as I was delighted to see him in the third season of Fargo - but as soon as its about his face getting projected in a CGI super-hunk, it got boring. Also, the bit about the soldiers hugging istantly afterwards… it was hard to take it seriously.

But it’s probably more profitable already given BvS’s production budget and far higher marketing investment.


I believe this is true, but we’ll never really know for sure because movie studios don’t normally drill down into the numbers that deeply.


I just assumed the training montage took place over a couple thousand years.


So the family and I saw this on Sunday. I think we all enjoyed it as a stand alone but none of us thought it was as good as say a Captain America movie. In fact I think there are a lot of similarities between WW and CA1. The first two Captain America movies were on FX yesterday and after watching CA1 again even my wife and daughter agreed that WW seemed to borrow freely from it.

One interesting result of watching the movie was my older daughter (27), who had no use for superhero movies spent the yesterday watching everything she could on Netflix (or elsewhere on line).


If we assume equal marketing (a very conservative assumption), I think WW is still far ahead, due to the stronger domestic performance and 100M lower production budget. Plus, it’s still raking it in.

Wonder Woman

production: 149M
domestic: 350M
foreign: 363M
D+F: 714M


production: 250M
domestic: 330M
foreign: 542M
D+F: 873M


Interesting that it’s not doing better overseas, especially compared to BvS. I guess I expected it to fare better than it would here state-side.