Oh, so I guess that’s what happened to me last night. I was queued as a DPS on my Paladin, because I’m still trying to get some quest rewards to fill out my tanking set, and to familiarize myself more with the fights. We zone into regular HoO, and it’s me, a resto shaman, shadow priest, mage and fury warrior. The fury warrior is marked “Tank”, and I can tell he’s a fury warrior because he’s dual-wielding 2-handers.
So I’m thinking “Okay, I guess he was questing before the queue popped,” but he just goes and charges right into that first pack as is. Naturally it doesn’t go that well, especially since I’m pulling aggro on everything I attack, and that first pull is kind of nasty.
I like to give people the benefit of the doubt, so I assume that he’s forgotten that he’s in his DPS spec, so let’s just give him a minute to swap out and whoops! There he goes again! Same thing - I’m pulling aggro off anything he’s “tanking”, so I say in chat “Am… I tanking?” the shaman says “you were during that fight” and the warrior says “whatever, let’s go fast” so I figure “fuck it”, switch to prot and start tanking. It’s pretty passive-aggressive, but the healer figures out what’s up, and we start making some actual progress. Clear the first boss with (mostly) no problems and we get to another of those tricky pulls. I start marking kill targets annnnnnd the warrior leaps heroically into the middle of them and starts attacking. I should mention at this point that he’s doing about 1200dps, which seems counter to his desire to “go fast”.
We almost wipe at the water elemental sub-boss, because the healer and the mage get bubbled, and nobody bothers to break them out - certainly not the warrior, because I can see him beside me at the boss. At this point I’ve had enough, so I vote to kick, which passes. The shadowpriest, who is second in dps behind me, also leaves. Possibly because I was not polite in my “reason for kicking”
Oh, and I just looked him up and it’s my mistake. He wasn’t dual-wielding two-handers. He had a 1H axe in mainhand, and a 2H Obsidium Executioner in his offhand. There are also a couple of other problems with his gear