I had these sitting around from last week, but I didn’t write down why they were connected. And I actually had to think about it for a second to remember my wording. These aren’t as good as Kelly Wand’s though, unfortunately, but how could they be?
3) Dazed and Confused and Wonder Boys
This is my weakest one. I think the connection is probably too obvious. But I didn’t pick both because they involve drugs, but more because both films give me the same feeling - kind of a meandering, relaxed feeling. One is about the after hours parties of high school kids, one is about campus life, but both are kind of about how people wander from place to place without a real destination in mind, but the journey is what matters. They both create a story out of very disconnected scenes, which I liked.
2) A Serious Man and Whale Rider
Both were movies which, at least for me, jumped to a whole new level when they both had a scene, roughly half-way through the movie, featuring a character weeping and pleading for the love of a father-figure / God-figure about their hopes and dreams. In the case of A Serious Man, it is Richard Kind sitting on the edge of the dried-up pool, crying and yelling at Hashem. And in Whale Rider, it is Keisha Castle-Hughes breaking down while reading a speech dedicated to her grandfather, who isn’t there.
I think A Serious Man is a far better movie, and in fact Whale Rider gets kind of boring near the end. But in both movies, I was absolutely floored by each moment. I had never seen anything from Richard Kind before that prepared me for what he did in that scene. And if you didn’t tear up a little during that scene in Whale Rider you have a heart of stone.
1) Magnolia and Children of Men
I may be the only one who had this interpretation of both of these movies, but I think both Magnolia and Children of Men are films about how characters react when put in a situation that is larger than themselves and over which they have no control. The movies are both: “okay, now you’re in this situation; what are you going to do?”
Many of my friends who saw Children of Men didn’t like it because they wish that there had been more explanation about why children weren’t being born, and wanted to know more about the world of the film. They also didn’t like it because of the way it left things unresolved - will Kee make it to the human project or not? For me, none of those things were the point - the movie was about how Theo dealt with being in this world, and the issue of having to protect this special individual. And once his story was over, the movie could end.
Likewise, in Magnolia, the opening scenes tell little vignettes of coincidence - like a scuba-diver who winds up in a treetop … how did he get up there? Then the movie jumps into a bunch of characters lives and we never really get any of those explanations for why these coincidences are happening again. I think the point was that the characters in Magnolia are like the people in those vignettes. They themselves can’t see the overall picture because they are inside their own life - they can’t see the hand of God controlling the coincidences, they just have to react and live their lives as best they can.